I have fished the gorge all my life and have been acusuide of this very thing. ya it may seem as bs in your eye’s but I was told that on federal water’s if I was to take as much as a six pac of beer I was guideing that was later cleared up but I was told that if eny money at all was exchanged or my boat was fuled up I ws guideing so this will be very interesting to see what Mary come’s up with trust me it aint worth it I was told if I was ever caught guideing I would never fish fg again so as of now I wont even take a dime for gas from my good buddy’s and sevral may get on hear and tell you I dont even let them pitch in . ya I think it is a bs law I think it is bs that I cant let my buddy’s help me out or even pic up the gas tab for the day hell I’am showing them over 20yr of lake trout exp wouldnt it be worth it and allso some of the guide’s get a little butt hurt if thay feel thay have some compatition just my exp and I aint dealing with it again so now you just have to be lucky enuf to be asked to go with me lol ASH
This post is funny and very good at the same time…[unsure]
At every tournament / fishing derby and people fishing together help pay for gas and other things needed for trips to /or for fishing trips, and if what is ben said is true then we are all in trouble with the law…[crazy]
Maybe I had better head for south of the border, oh waite I’m going there in December any way…[;)]![]()
yeah this post is moot… I am very familiar with utah state code and I can tell you there is not code which would allow you to charge someone for splitting gas with you on a fishing trip, I dont know about wyoming and I am sure it is different… even if you could find a technical violation, you would be below the threshold of probably cause, requiring “intent” and well below the threshold of beyond a reasonable doubt…
Allright, the BS stops here! If any of you have have ever fished with somebody else or next to in your boat, tube, toon, shoreline, etc. or have even talked about fishing together I want you to know that the LAW will prosecute you and others![crazy]
Give me a break people! Why does this thread even exist? I’m going fishing with my apprentice and a fellow BFT’er on Sunday, going to launch at the Strawberry marina around 7:30 and I am going to willingly accept gas money.I WILL WILLINGLY SHARE WHAT I KNOW ABOUT THE BERRY ON MY BOAT!!! If anyone has a problem with this look for the BFT flag and you can call the fish and game to come arrest me, because after all I’m a lawbreaker, right?
This is the bs that ran me off the last site I belonged to. There is always somebody that thinks they can put an elder (no offense, bassrods) that knows more about catching a certain species than they will ever know about fishing period. (note the period [;)])
What ever happened to ‘average’ people that just like to fish? I slipped out of my bass fishing club to become a member of BFT and fish with people like me. I’m not wealthy, I don’t have a ‘better than your boat’ (although I do have a nice boat
) attittude, I belong to this site because as I tell others “it’s just a bunch of regular people that like to fish and want to share their experiences with others” C’mon now, let’s just get back to the basics.
I have learned more than I could pass on from the members of this site and it has made me a better fisherman, which in turn I pass along to others that fish with me and have become members or ‘lurkers’, either way, what ever happened to “let’s go fishing this weekend”? Why does there have to be so much politics and rules and contraversy?There isa proclamation that states all of that. Let the law worry about lawbreakers and not people who want to fish for pure enjoyment. OK, I’m done venting now, now let’s just go fsh4fun.
Can you let me know how much you make of your gas money[;)] so I know how much time it will take to make a 1,000,000[crazy]…Have fun and good fishing…
Hey Cliff, I’m gonna chime in here. Hats off to ya for having thick skin and putting up with all the stuff that gets dumped on ya. You get more than your share.
The big issue here is HOW ARE THE LAWS WRITTEN…AND HOW ARE THEY INTERPRETED AND ENFORCED? In defense of DWR and other agencies involved, it is tough to write laws to protect both fish and fishermen without leaving some loopholes or creating complications in figuring out exactly what is meant.
Regulations against anybody receiving ANY FORM of payment for “guiding” without a license are a good idea. It protects anglers who would otherwise be conned into paying some unlicensed goober to take them fishing…and who would have a bad experience and not be able to do anything about it. It also provides for those agencies to get more money to enforce all of the regulations. But, it is not just about the money.
**The problem comes up when an overzealous ranger or other official interprets the laws as including “shared expenses” between fishing buddies as falling into the “guide fee” category. I have asked a couple of officers about that in the past and they replied that TECHNICALLY it was a violation to pay even gas money for a fishing trip…but that they personally would never even think about citing somebody. **
It becomes an individual issue situation that an official has to review on a case by case basis. As has been suggested in this thread…how high do the “expenses” have to be, before they could be interpreted as becoming “guide fees”. Splitting a gas fill up 50/50 is much different that paying $450 at the end (or beginning) of the trip…“to cover all of the expenses”. And, “creative” guides can always find a clever way to label whatever they charge somebody going fishing with them.
That is only one of several regulations that I have questioned over the years. Another is not being able to hand off a fish to a fellow angler…or someone else who wants or needs it more than you do. I’m not just talking about hatchery pets. I object that is illegal to give a kid a white bass or a bullhead on Utah Lake, when they are catching nothing and you can’t keep them off your line. If a CO sees you do it, you get a hefty fine. The law says you have to make the transfer at your home or a frozen food locker…with all kinds of written documentation of the transfer.
Another issue is the filleting regs. No filleting on some waters, because of slot limits. Okay, I can deal with that. But, the regulation about leaving a patch of skin on the fillets, for identification. What good is filleting if you have to go back and remove the skin when you get home. It takes longer to remove the patch of skin than to fillet and skin the whole fish. And, if a CO is unable to tell what kind of fish it is, in any given water, without a skin patch, they need more courses in fisheries biology. I am not a biologist but I can tell almost any species of fish by looking at the fillet. I have heard first hand reports of officers issuing tickets for that infraction. Not right.
If the DWR needs more money from citations, they need to spend more time at Strawberry. Still far too many slot cutts being removed from the lake. And, when you remind the offenders that there is a slot there is usually one of two reactions. 1. Mind your own business. 2. Gee, I didn’t know. Yeah, right.
There are plenty of other “little things” that could be tweaked to make fishing more enjoyable for all without hurting the fisheries. Sorry to “hijack” this thread. Maybe someone else might want to start a “Regulations Reviews” thread…to get some of the other things up for discussion. Then, we need to send a link to DWR. Some of their folks are members and others are frequent readers (lurkers) anyway, and BFT is often discussed (and cussed) at DWR offices. Hopefully we can become part of the solution and not just part of the problem.
Wow! That’s good info to have about Flaming Gorge. Thanks Chuck, fishley and Wyobraz. That seems awfully overzealous on the part of the feds, but I’m glad to have the info. Frankly, nothing I hear about the feds or the Forest Service surprises me any more, especially when it comes to the Gorge.
it has nothing to do with wyoming fg is on ashley national forest so the dwr cant do jack about you guideing on fed water’s that is all regulated by the gov so tell eny game warden you like thay cant do eny thing even if thay see you hand me 450 big one’s but on the other hand, what ever this is a dumb a$$ thread but it would help some to look beyond the DWR for there info just come up to the gorge and fish for about 2 month’s strait and take all your buddy’s out and tell me in 5month’s what your statis is lmfao It’s just info guy’s from guy’s that have delt with it so take it how ever you want I allready have…ASH and people wonder why I wont post lake trout report’s eny more lmfao is bft on a down slide[crazy]
Man, I can’t believe how many people got their knickers in a twist over this!
Personally, I think the info is great to have, especially on how the rule is interpreted at Flaming Gorge. It’s pretty standard for fishing partners from down here to split the costs of truck and boat gas. It will make me think twice about how to do those arrangements with that kind of enforcement attitude.
I might have posted the same type thing for the Gorge as Bassrods did and left myself exposed as a result.
And, Ash, I understand your feelings, and feel your pain.
well i know first hand that Ash will not except any comp for a fishing trip! i tried to give him money and other things for the fishing trips we have gone togther on. but he will not do it. he said that some of the guide up there will turn in someone for some realy peety stuff.
a lot of pepole in utah think FG is just another lake. but if you spend some time up there and mingel with some of the area’s fisher men.. you’ll find all is not pechy in fishing haven.. some pepole that guid find someone showing fishermen how to fish for free or cost of gas as a thret to there lively hood. and will go after them through the law. and as a lot of you guy’s know once the law gett’s mixed into anything it’s not going to be prity.(red tape and loopholes can take years to sort out). it my not be right but it is happing there and is a problem for good guy’s just trying to have some fun and catch some fish..
After I sent the e-mail to Mari, it occurred to me that IF this is going on at the Gorge, then RANGER education is needed.
Again, I’ll keep the salt ready, but there is no law anywhere that was written with intent to prevent Tom, Dick and Harry from splitting trip costs. Fed or State. Zero.
Although the F-Gorge Ranger District may not have been aware of this website before, now that they know it exists they can see the traffic it gets. We’re a big audience, and one of their roles is to educate. So let 'em educate us OR the Rangers.
If this is happening at the Gorge, it needs to stop. No law was written with this intent, and I’ll bet dollars to doughnuts the FG Ranger District is filled with reasonable people who agree. This can’t possibly be justified.
And if it is the rule, you can be sure I will contact the Wyoming Attorney Generals Office Civil Division to get this changed.
It would take a bit of time, but it would be a slam dunk code revision.
thease guys just shared real life exp with us and you still pitching the salt thing. think they are making this up? i know differnt. and ash would not even let me buy him a snow after fishing with him for 3 days. i was pissed. i always pay my share! so for it to be this way sucked for me. i had a blast fishing. but didnt like not being able to contribute to the exp. that why next time i fish with him its in my boat. lol
Don I did not post anything about the Gorge I said Jordanelle, I could care less about what any one says about the Gorge or the Berry If some one goes with me or if I go with them we pay our fair share…
and that is how it should be split down the middle I hope it does get made clear then my old laidy will let me fish a lot more lol.Bassrods I enjoy your post’s so keep on keepin on and ignore the peanet gallery as many have to around hear even worse now the dwr site is gone ASH
Hey Ash, thanks for posting back to this post. Oh and I also had a blast fishing kokes with you earlier this year. but like ken said I allways pay my way so next time it will also be in my boat and I will pick you up on the way in. that old broken rod you gave me has become a 51in. mack ice fish rod. so let me know when the ice gets save and I will come up to try it out with you. later chuck
The Wyoming guide’s board is anal. A friend and I leased a ranch and sold trespass permits for hunting. We were so afraid of being charged with illegally outfitting that we refused to meet the hunters at the ranch. Instead we met them in town and gave them a map and a key to the ranch. The guide’s board still went after us. They wanted $500 per hunter we had signed up and said even selling a trespass permit with no in-the-field help constituted illegal outfitting. My friend agreed to plea guilty, but I refused to allow him to do that. No matter what, you should never plead guilty to something of which you’re not guilty. I’m not ready to lie to a judge and tell him or her that I’m guilty of something I never did. I wasn’t as easily cowed as many people, having read the law in detail, and so we hired a lawyer and fought the investigator who had charged us. Our lawyer made him look like a fool because nothing he said was reflected in the law. The guide’s board decided to drop the case and even awarded my friend a guide’s license; so now he really competes with the other outfitters in Wyoming. If the guide’s board had not backed down, we would have asked for a jury trial. We might have lost, regardless of the law, because we could have ended up with a bunch of jurors who don’t like fishing or hunting or who don’t like non-residents. But I’m sure we would have won on appeal because a guilty verdict would not have reflected the law. And that’s the sort of thing appeals courts focus on. So what’s the connection here? If you want the guide’s board in Wyoming after you, ask for reimbursement for any expenses on a fishing trip. You’ll find yourself with the common dilemma of having to make two poor choices: 1) hire a lawyer to protect you (ours cost only about $3,000 but most would charge $7,000 or more), or 2) plead guilty to something of you’re not guilty because it’s a lot cheaper. Many people opt for Choice No. 2 every year. In Alaska the game wardens often issue tickets if they just have a suspicion you’ve broken a law. They don’t need evidence. That’s because they know you’re not going to travel back to Alaska to defend yourself, and you’re not going to hire a lawyer. The wardens commonly weigh game meat that has been packed out of the field, and if you’ve eaten too much of your caribou, or if a bear ate a good chunk of it, you’re going to get a ticket for wanton waste of game meat. And do you want to spend several thousand bucks to defend yourself against false accusations when you might find yourself before a judge or jury of Alaskans who hate hunters, especially non-resident hunters?
Well we hit the Nell (Jordanelle) and we split the cost of gas will post the hole story later…![]()
I hope they don’t put us in jail…[;)]
[reply]
Quote: "I wasn’t as easily cowed as many people, having read the law in detail, and so we hired a lawyer and fought the investigator who had charged us. So what’s the connection here? If you want the guide’s board in Wyoming after you, ask for reimbursement for any expenses on a fishing trip. You’ll find yourself with the common dilemma of having to make two poor choices: 1) hire a lawyer to protect you (ours cost only about $3,000 but most would charge $7,000 or more), or 2) plead guilty to something of you’re not guilty because it’s a lot cheaper. Many people opt for Choice No. 2 every year. "
As I have written to others here, please don’t post bad info. The Outfitters Board doesn’t even have authority over fisherman, only hunting.
There is no law out there that contemplates that Tom, Dick, and Harry, fishin buddies, are violating the law by goin to the Gorge and splitting trip costs.
And the FG RD is not going to tell me otherwise. To do so, they would have to provide me with a Federal or State Code supporting their authoritative opinion, and there isn’t one.
Refer back to my post #23: There has to be an element of (potential) gain in order to constitute a commercial enterprise, which would in turn require that commercial enterprise to be licensed.
It doesn’t exist here. Just buds goin fishin. No gain, no net income, just cost-covering.
Now if someone wants to post the code section violation noted on one of these tickets several of you are talking about, that would be helpful. Otherwise, just sit tight and let me handle this.
**I edited your post and increased the size of the lettering. You can edit your own posts to change not only the content, but the script type, size and color. After clicking on “edit”, highlight the copy you want to change and then click on the bold black “A” (not the A with the line under it) over near the right side of the toolbar. That will bring up the menu. Choose what you want to have the copy look like…size, bold, color, etc…and then click OK. **
Once you get familiar with setting up, formatting and editing, you should be able to do that in the original post without having to go back and edit. But, the edit function is always there to tweak your own posts.
Your right the Wyoming Outfitters board has absolutely zero authority over fishing guides. Wyoming is no different than Utah when it comes to requiring a license for fishing guides, you don’t need one.
The requirement for having a “Special Use Permit” that is issued by the National Park Service to be a fishing guide is only on waters that are on federal lands such as National Forests, National Wildlife Refuges, and National Parks. This applys in every state in our country!
**Toyguy I personaly hope your are correct on this, but I did not post bad information. If I thought for a second that by posting false info would scare someone from traveling to the Gorge I guarantee I would have posted the info long before now, LOL. The info that I posted was from two different lectures that I have been given from two different Rangers this last spring. If you can’t trust what the authoritive figure is telling you what can you trust? I was also told by the Rangers that if found guilty it is punishable by up to a $5000 fine, up to a year in jail, and loss of hunting and fishing privliges for five years. **
Once again hopefully for all of us fisherman you are correct, and thanks for pursuing this further. But the Forest Service needs to not only teach us what the rules are but they also need to teach thier own Rangers becasue I am not the only one that fishes the Gorge regularly that has been told the same thing.