Fish guide's in Utah?

Part of the Gorge is in Utah last time I checked,:face_with_tongue: but you still need a guide license. I am pretty sure the guide license for the Gorge is issued through the Forest Service and not through either state, and can be checked by the either states G&F or a Forest Ranger. If I am wrong on this TarponJim I am sure will correct me.


I know you do travel to the Gorge occasionally so this is just an FYI.

you got it bassrods. and for the record i would guide you on a ice trip for 1/2 the cost of gas and a bass trip with ya on nelly.. [sly] and i would pay 1/2 the gas in your boat no problem..

Wyobraz wrote:


if any of you ever get an invite to go fishing with me the only expense you would have is your travel to Wyoming,


Then I would buy you lots of dinner in appreciation.



because I sure as hell will never chance it.


****I know you’re not trying to stir up the pot, but it’s these kind of statements that effectively do. Chance what? A fine? Imprisonment? The time involved to get this sorted out?

I envision sitting in front of an Administrative Hearing Officer stating: “Yes, I took gas money, but only to the extent of my expense, and there was no personal gain” and have him pronounce me guilty of operating a guide service without a license.

There has to be an element of (potential) gain in order to constitute a commercial enterprise, which would in turn require that commercial enterprise to be licensed.

It doesn’t exist here.

This is absurd. I will look at Utah Code for clarification when I get a chance, but I know it won’t be today.

Flaming Gorge and Lake Powell it’s called a concessionair’s license and the Gorge is regulated by the Forest Service…but I have never been talking about the Gorge.

Some of the orginal post was deleted by kentofnsl.

Man Saberfish I never said anything bad at all about Bassrods not in this post or ever, but obviously some of you think I have so I will probably get in trouble anyway[;)]. I think it is great that he is willing to teach others.


My whole contribution to this thread was about ANYONE sharing expenses fishing the Gorge, not just Bassrods. I’m sorry you thought it was stupid 'cause I thought it was informative, to each thier own I guess, LOL. But times have changed at the Gorge my friend, and this is the way it is like it or not. I personally can’t stand the rules I think they are idiotic and I don’t fish as much as I would like because of them. So I guess people either abide by the rules or break them, but at least they now know the rules.

What I have been told by officers is if it takes $150 to fill my boat up and you pay for half the $75 dollars that you paid constitutes a gain. I don’t agree with it at all but thats what I have been told and the presedence that has been set in the past at the Gorge.


I don’t chance it because it is not worth my time too, and it is not worth the risk of loosing fishing or hunting rights by going in front of some goofy judge that may not see it the way you do. Like I said you guys do what you want I am just trying to share info with you all, I am not trying to justify the rule.

Braz,

My comments were not directed to you.
I was just adding to the thread, and posted it under what I thought was the post above mine.

No cheap shots at anyone in particular. My comments were directed to the over all thread itself.

I can’t get over the way the some members on here attack for no reason, rather than posting positive comments. There are so many people who post on here that have great knowledge and can add so much to the forum, which by the way, is what the forum was intended for.

The only time that I fire a direct shot across some one’s bow, is when a post is so outlandish, and full of BS, that I can’t control my fingers.

[reply]
[/reply]

In forums people can express their “opinions” on subjects. I can totally respect WYOBRAZ’s take in wyoming they do things differently. If I ever get the opportunity to fish with you I would either offer a trip in exchange, pick up the tab at dinner and bring a few lures, and or a night at mikes astro lounge… Oh wait that would be if we didn’t get along. Anyway trading trips is a good way to improve skills and meet new people with similar intrests. Unfortunately Cliff has been being bashed because some do not know common courtesy to pay back a favor! I like the fact that people offer an open seat in the boat and clarify expenses. Keep it up I plan on doing the same this summer!

Part of post deleted by kentofnsl to hopefully keep this thread from being locked.

OK, I am tired of the fear, speculation and paranoia of this thread.

So I went straight to the horse’s mouth. Flaming Gorge RD, Mary Campbell. 435 784 3445.

I said I would send her the question in an e-mail. Here is exactly what I wrote her:

“The debate is: If you own a boat, and bring friends along to fish in the Gorge, and if gas expenses are split equally among all the occupants of the boat, meaning there is no financial gain to the boat owner, he’s only covering his cost, is that boat owner considered a guide, and therefore be required to be licensed?

I cannot possibly imagine the State of Wyoming or any Federal Agency attempting to fine or prosecute somebody for this! But there are replies on the Board that swear this is happening. Read the whole post to get a flavor of this. It’s quite interesting. But absurd.

We all look forward to hearing about what the rules are.

Thank you very much!”

Wyobraz, I will absolutely apologize to you, publicly on this Board and put salt on my foot as I insert in into my mouth if I’m wrong, but you need to stop with the anecdotes. You are spreading fear and misinformation. You are not going to go in front of a goofy judge and lose your fishing license, for splitting gas money, or covering only your costs amongst boat occupants. It is not going to happen! Fear here is clouding views on the repercussions of such a ruling.

The uproar amongst private fisherman would be great. And I believe the State of Wyoming and Utah know this. Not to mention this is completely unenforceable. What are they gonna do, review receipts boat side?

I’ll get the salt ready, but let’s see what Mary has to say.

Your e-mail should have read more like:


…I have a friend that is willing to take me to the Flaming Gorge and teach me how to fish there as long as I pay for half of the gas. Is this legal without a concesionaires license for Flaming Gorge?..



This is the type of example I have been refering to. Too bad Sockeyeslayer wasn’t around today, he would be able to tell ya his experiences with showing people how to fish for Kokes and the guiding rules. Oh well no need to apologize if your wrong I could care less and besides come 3PM today my time here at BFT is done for at least several years.

Whobraz,

Where ya headed, I guess no burger and beer for us at mikes astro lounge then huh?

LOL, I might take ya up on that Astro burger someday but it will have to wait awhile. Everything is on the Wyo board as to what is going on.


Later All,

So the legal distinction is “teaching” , as opposed to “sharing my experience”?

Without financial gain, doesn’t stand a chance, IMO. No element of illegal benefit received, and there’s no commercial enterprise occurring.

I hope she responds, soon.

Let’s get clarification, and be well on wherever your travels take you.

Good luck in your endeavours Braz. We still gotta “trade” tigers for macks one of these days.:sunglasses:

Our question is being followed up on. Here’s what she’s written so far:

“I hope to have your answer by Monday. I will review the
website with the District Special Use Administrator and we will contact you.”

Stay tuned.

Wyobraz , you will be missed . Thanks for your contribution . I do believe you are right . If you “guide” on U.S. Forest land you need to be licensed . That would include the Berry . Has nothing to do with DWR or the State of Utah .

[reply]In utah you do NOT need a (GUIDE license) for fishing, if you want me to guide you my fee is $450.00 per day…[/reply] Absolutely true Bassrods. You people think Cliff is making money at $35.00 a trip? Hardly. If someone wants to get on a guide get on Steve Stoner for exposing Boulder Mountain on Roughin it Outdoors. Now he needs to be hammered on. But Bassrods is harmless.

what is the animosity towards bassrods… I must be missing something because he seems to taking in the shorts a lot lately, why???

[#002850]Ho - Lee - CRAP! Fishhound and I sharred the costs to fish the Berry today. I wonder which one of us should consider hiding from the law? Or, maybe we are both in trouble.

For too many things any more … It’s all about the money.

Just a thought on the issue, If “you/I” pay maverick 150 on a credit card to fill a tank on a boat, then your “partner/fatherinlaw/buddy/freind” gives you 75 bucks and picks up samiches for lunch. would that not in the eyes of the “law” of any kind constitute money laundering? you take the receipt and, in theory, claim the 150 on taxes after receiving half of that back as cash, does that not also become tax fraud?

If that is the case, I better save my dad NOW. I have given him back 20, or 40, or 100 even after he paid for stuff cause we were both “there” and it was easier for him to pay for it to save time, then i get him later with the greenbacks…fishing, camping, trips to dineyland…the list goes on and on…I am a felon!! LOL…[crazy]

really all, if you take the kids next door fishin and their dad slips you a 20 when yall get home, is that the same thing or is that reimbursment for the individuals expense.

my point is, there are many different ways for this kind of thing to be interpreted, but i have learned that just about anything you need to interperet can be either legal or illegal…it just depends on how many witnesses there are and who they work for.

I would think, and i may be wrong, that for a individual to get ticketed for “guiding without license” the issuing officer would have to witness some kind of money exchange taking place. i mean they cant arrest a prostitute unless they see her take the cash…same principal, different line of work. unless you pimp fish.[angelic]