**If I thought for a second that by posting false info would scare someone from traveling to the Gorge I guarantee I would have posted the info long before now, LOL. **
**If I thought for a second that by posting false info would scare someone from traveling to the Gorge I guarantee I would have posted the info long before now, LOL. **
What a load of horse !@#$ if a couple of guys want to go out and fish and split the expense then there nothing wrong that, thats like saying you and you dad go out fishing spit the expense and you dad gets a ticket for guiding.
Bassrod an experienced fisherman he has helped out quite a few people on this board and if he wants to share his experience with others then it should be considered an oppurtunity.
Its crap like this that ruined the DWR board…
Here’s the deal, why would anyone pay $450.00 to go drop shot Jordenell? If you’re going to fork out that kind of money, go to a real lake and hire a real guide.
Welcome to the board, but lighten up. It was not Wyobraz who posted that. It was Bassrods. And, if you knew him and his abilities, you would not question it.
Jordanelle IS a real lake…with world class trophy smallmouth fishing…because of the slot and regulation.
Did you just jump in to stir the pot or is your question a real one? This thread has largely run its course. Let it drift off in the current.
Wow. Where did that come from?
First off, yes I do know bassrods and his abilities. Quite frankly I’m not really all that impressed by them. That’s just my opinion. But that’s not the issue.
Second, yes, Jordanelle is a fine lake. World class? That might be a bit of a stretch don’t you think? To pay that kind of cash to go out and now lets be honest, catch a few decent smallies while drop shotting really doesn’t seem like all that great of a deal.
Third, no I did not come in to stir the pot. I posted what I thought is a legitimate statement that pertained directly to the thread and I made no personal attack of any kind.
If this is how people are treated on this site, perhaps I should look elsewhere for fishing discussions.
I think you missed the point completely.
Cliff isn’t advertising guiding services… he was personally called out for telling people that he would take them out (not guide them) if they would be willing to split the costs. Google it… there are guides that charge $250-$300 for Jordanelle. If he was truly guiding (like he was being accused of) then of course he would charge much more.
**I apologize. With some of the new “drop ins” and their “agendas” lately, I guess I wrongly guessed that you might just be a part of the problem and not a part of the solution. We had to institute some more aggressive moderating to try to keep things civil. **
I know Cliff too. And, I sure wouldn’t put up that kind of money to listen to him all day. (Sorry Cliff) I catch plenty of smallies and some decent ones too…and I do not dropshot. It works well, a majority of the time. But, even Bassrods will tell you that he fishes with several different methods…even on the same day and in the same spots. Some folks have him pegged as a “one trick pony” because of his sponsor (Mojo) and the number of bass he reports as being caught on dropshot. But, he is definitely a multi species and multi tackle kinda guy. Like many of us, he just plain enjoys the heck out of fishing.
I HAVE fished all over the country, and across the borders north and south. My evaluation of “world class” might be a bit extreme…but it is the closest we got in Utah. Well, maybe Strawberry for cutts. And, of course, the subject water of this hijacked and abused thread…Flaming Gorge. Paying anglers come from far and wide for the world reknowned mack snagging rituals.
There, did we bring it back on track?
Again…sorry for the abrupt welcome.
I think you need to go back and read what has been said and look at the intent…
First off I don’t guide no one and don’t want to…
And you don’t know me at all!!! All you have to go on is what you have read on some sites or what others may have said…
And Yes Jordanelle IS A WORLD CLASS SMALL MOUTH BASS FISHERY and I think you did come here to try and stir the pot and if this is all you want to do, take your own advice…
This post was put on here only to get the response it has, no good has come from it or will …
Are you quite thru bassrods? Or do you wish to stir the pot more?
And yes, I do know you. I know you through SUBA and ABA. If I had come to stir the pot you unmistakenly would have know it.
As far as Jordenanelle is concerened, it is a fine lake and has many nice fish in it. But don’t kidd yourself. It’s not world class. For that matter, Newcastle in So.Utah for its size has a much better smallmouth fishery. It’s only problem is its size.
All post are ment to provoke some sort of response. That’s why we all make posts. If you made some sort of post and nobody replyed in any way shape or form, chances are you’d quit making them. It’s called General Discusion.
Note:
Reformatting success! My first uploaded pass at this Reply looked horrible. At least for me, the key was to compose this in Wordpad, not Notepad or Word. Both of the latter just simply messed up any formatting attempts. Thanks to Old Coot and TD for their advice.
Ok, Mari and I talked. She has been pleasant and helpful.
There is a section of US law that is about how National Forest land can be used. It’s called the Code of Federal Regulations, Title 36 – Parks, Forests and Public Property. Flaming Gorge is governed by these rules. Title 36, Part 251 talks about how these places can be used.
But any and every use is a “special use”:
(a) All uses of National Forest System lands, improvements, and resources,… are designated ``special uses.‘’
Then it says before you use the area for whatever your special use is, you gotta get a permit:
(a con’t) Before conducting a special use, individuals or entities must submit a proposal to the authorized officer and must obtain a special use authorization from the authorized officer,
Unless…:
(c) A special use authorization is not required for noncommercial recreational activities, such as camping, picnicking, hiking, fishing, boating, hunting, and horseback riding, or for noncommercial activities involving the expression of views, such as assemblies, meetings, demonstrations, and parades, unless:
Don’t worry about that “unless”, it doesn’t pertain. But note the word “noncommercial”. Like I’ve written, there’s no commerce goin on here, just buddies splittin fishing costs.
However, this Section 251 has two parts to it. The second part has some definitions. One of the definitions is for what “Commercial” means, and the other is what a Guide is. Surprisingly, the definition of “Commercial” speaks to the opposite of what I have been writing about how there has to be a profit involved if any one of you is to be considered a guide when taking gas money. BUT, it’s only within the context of the wording before where it reads:“where the primary purpose is the sale of a good or service”.* *That’s not you guys. Your primary purpose is goin fishin with a buddy; it’s not to promote/represent yourself as a guide.
Here’s that “Commercial use” definition:
Commercial use or activity–any use or activity on National Forest System lands (a) where an entry or participation fee is charged, or (b) where the primary purpose is the sale of a good or service, and in either case, regardless of whether the use or activity is intended to produce a profit.
So why does it add this “doesn’t matter if it’s for a profit” stuff? My guess would be Not for Profit groups using the area without a permit.
But so far we’re all in the clear. So here comes the definition of a Guide. As you read this, “pecuniary” means money.
Guiding–providing services or assistance (such as supervision, protection, education, training, packing, touring, subsistence, transporting people, or interpretation) for pecuniary remuneration or other gain to individuals or groups on National Forest System lands.
Uh-oh! You’re taking money! You’re a Guide! Right? Wrong.
It’s only if you’re taking money for providing services or assistance. “Providing services” means offering your service self on a regular basis to people you don’t know. Sharing your boat with a buddy is not “providing services”.
So there’s the technical support behind why you guys should just go to the Gorge, split expenses, and have fun.
So what about the Ranger anecdotes about hassling guys and maybe giving tickets? Admittedly, troubling. There are certainly LE out there with “a little too much blue light in their blood”.
Mary seemed quite surprised, and not necessarily convinced, that this was going on. Despite my “blue light” quote, I’d want to see the code violations on those tickets before passing judgement myself. But, if it happens to someone in the future, politely get the Ranger’s name. I suggest explaining this topic has been discussed on this board, that the FG RD was involved, and that you’d just like to get some further clarification from the RD. I don’t suggest just asking his name without explaining why. It’ll just piss off a person who’s a hardliner to begin with. However, if explaining results in you getting a ticket just cuz you’ve thrown some legal stuff at him… Tough call, so don’t be Perry Mason, maybe.
Don’t be afraid to have a difference of opinion with someone who has authority. Generally, it’s not what you do, it’s how you do it. And if Ranger education is needed, so be it.
I forgot to ask where a hearing takes place if you get a ticket and want to contest it. I also don’t know if that hearing can be done by phone. But I’ve been a part of a phone hearing before, so maybe.
So now that you’re armed with CFR 36, part 251, go fishing!
TG
Thanks for the research, but it is a sad day when you need a lawyer to draw up a contract, a whitness to see the exchange of money, and a full receipt log of expenses just so you and a fishing buddy can split gas going to fish the gorge. If that’s breaking the law then lock me up because anyone who invites me fishing is getting some cash stuffed in thier pocket for expenses.
Good for you orvis1. Far too many people feel an invite on a boat ends when you put the boat back on the trailer. A few club anglers I have known don’t even offer to help with fuel costs which is always a stunner to me. It’s not cheap to haul a boat around not to mention driving around the lake looking for fish.
Thx, Orvis.
If “Joe Fishermen’s” have been cited for this, that is sad.
But I think (hope) bringing the awareness to both the anglers and the Rangers will end the misunderstandings.
I say go fish in peace and with confidence. I know I plan on it.
Thanks for the research on this, it does clear up a few things. My close friends will need help out from now on.
I was aware of the rules and definitions that you posted, they are available on the Forest Service website under the “Special Use Permit” section. My only concern still would be like I stated earlier is if I posted on this site that I would be willing to take a stranger to the Gorge and teach them how to fish its waters, if they would help with expenses, could that be considered guiding. To me that is still a grey area that I am not willing to touch.
Wyobraz -
You’re welcome.
I myself would be comfortable with the stranger thing legally, it’s the stranger in my boat part that I would struggle with…![]()
Hope your travels are good to you.
TG