The walleye fishing in Willard right now is a “good news - bad news” situation. There are not as many walleye as in previous years, but the average size seems to have increased and there are more bigguns being landed…by a chosen few…and by some guys with a lot of dumb luck.
**The BIG DRAIN three years ago in late fall, after they discovered the leak in the dike, was the beginning of the current situation. Walleyes are drawn to current and the water being sucked out through the outflow pipe vacuumed a lot of walleyes out and down into the canal below. Lots of wipers and catfish too. But there were a bunch of the “happy harvesters” who lined up down there and snagged truckloads of stacked up walleyes. **
That reduced the total biomass of walleyes in Willard, but it wasn’t all bad. The next two spawning seasons were not good for the walleyes because the water did not reach up into the rocks. A lot of walleyes used the rocks for spawning, but during low water they had to use the inlet channel. Not all bad because they were protected from all but a handful of poachers.
In short, there were plenty of walleye that survived the BIG SUCK. Enough to repopulate Willard Bay within the next 3 to 5 years…especially with the high water being back up into the rocks. The survivors have had more food and more space in the customary walleye hangouts. They are healthier and bigger now than they have been for a long time.
But, you have not been catching them with the same success rate as in years past. Hey, they are still walleye and they will bite when and where they want…for who they want. They are always tough for most folks, but when their numbers are down that makes it even worse.
One of my favorite fishing sayings is “You can’t ketch 'em where they ain’t.” With walleyes, in Willard, there is a lot more water where they ain’t than where they is. It takes a combination of lots of experience, good sonar, current reports from “insiders”, presenting the right offering at the right speed and the right depth…for any given day…and a lot of luck.
On a daily basis some first time wiper troller will come back into the ramp with several walleyes in the livewell, asking “What are these things?”. And, the dedicated (demented) walleye chasers come back in cursing their luck because all they could get on their fancy custom made bottom bouncers and worm harnesses were wipers and catfish. Go figure.
I once witnessed a tin boat full of drunks trolling a big silver spoon at mach 3 along the dike outside the south marina. They only had one rod and kept trading off, after one guy caught a fish. I saw them crank in several walleyes in a row…all big ones…while throwing their empties over the side to “GPS” the best spots. To a “knowledgeable” walleye fisherman, they were doing EVERYTHING wrong. But, to them, they had it knocked. They were the world’s best walleye fishermen. Who can argue the logic?
**Bottom line. Like gold, walleyes are where you find them. But, finding them is no guarantee you will catch them. They may chow down at night on a school of shad, and then belly down in the mud during the following day. Or, if you get lucky, their dinner bell might sound at 2 o’clock in the afternoon and you will start picking them up at all depths and all speeds on whatever you are dragging. **
**They can make you talk to yourself. But, they sure are fun and they sure are tasty. **