petition for tiger in the berry

I kinda said you were toast before ya got all ablaze. And it’s got less to do with the slay 'em and filet 'em crowd than about protecting the Bear Lake Cutts. They aren’t very likely to introduce another predatory species that will both compete with, and prey upon the cutts.

I’m not sure the other reserve populations of BL Cutthroats qualify as certified pure strain. In other words; the Bear Lake Cutthroats in Strawberry have been tested to verify that they are genetically identical to the Bear Lake Cutts in Bear Lake. If the BL Cutts in Scofield, or Panguitch or wherever have been in a body of water that has had other trout that aren’t sterile, the UDWR would have to do a lot of expensive DNA testing to prove that the cutthroats are genetically pure Bear Lake Cutts.

I’m not a big fan of the Bear Lake Cutts myself. They have a nasty habit of fighting like a dish rag until they are a few feet from being landed. And then they use all of their saved up energy to roll up in your line. They do a pretty good job of breaking your line if you aren’t ready for it. But the agreements that were worked out with the USFWS to protect the BL Cutts have to be honored. Otherwise they will severely restrict the fishing at Bear Lake. It ain’t gonna be easy to change the way things are.

They didn’t kill all of the chubs. They knew before they poisoned Strawberry that there would be some fish survive the treatment. I guess you weren’t around for all of the festivities. For several years after the treatment, the rainbows were sterilized by feeding them food pellets that were treated with methyl testosterone. The FDA got involved. They didn’t approve of people eating fish that were treated with a hormone that wasn’t on their list of safe additives to food. OSHA didn’t like the way the hatchery guys were being exposed to the stuff. For a few years there were no rainbows being planted at Strawberry. Now the rainbows that they plant are triploids. Meaning they have three sets of chromosomes. When their ovaries or testes try to produce egg or milt, it is impossible for the resulting eggs or milt to be haploid. When a normal animal produces gametes they are haploid, the union of two haploid gametes produces a diploid creature, which would therefore be able to reproduce. Triploids can’t reproduce.

It’s not very likely that you’re gonna get much changed at Strawberry. Don’t let me be the one to put a damper on your efforts, just let me be the one to tell you to keep your expectations based on reality, not fantasy.

RE “Utah DWR loves the slay 'em then fillet 'em crowd and will give in to them every dang time.”

From Mr. Wards reply
“One possibility would be to switch rainbow production for tigers. However, based on angler opinion surveys we regularly do at Strawberry, I do not think this would be a popular option. Most anglers want more rainbows, not fewer, or none if we made the switch.”

Don’t the folks that like the rainbows get a say? It is true that many of the Strawberry anglers want rainbows. Not just the hook & cookers, but a few trophy and fly guys screech for more rainbows too. I don’t think you can blame the DWR nearly as much as you can your own fellow anglers, based on the limitations the division has laid out.

If we’re talking solely about the fighting capabilities, tigers are much superior to cutts. (that’s the only way they are superior to them) But we all know they are not going to do anything to the cutt population. If anyone had that in their mind, you just weren’t thinking in reality. Never going to happen.

As stated in Alan Ward’s response, if tigers were to come in, they’d replace the bows. All things equal, I’d rather catch a 20+ inch bow than a 20+ inch tiger. Any day of the week, and it isn’t even close. Tigers were a novelty at one point, but as was stated early in this thread, they are everywhere now. They just aren’t that cool anymore.

So I’m in the crowd of not only no…but h…well, you get the point. Strawberry is an incredible fishery. If we are looking to improve places, that’s probably one of the last fishery in Utah I would try and start with.

well they did kill all the chubs so the must of got all the rainbows to

:sunglasses:There are still lots of chubs in Strawberry. But not many small ones. The cutts are keeping the newly spawned chubs cleaned up pretty good. The remaining chubs are pretty big…and getting bigger. It will soon be like Starvation…just a few old ugly chubosaurs.


On the other hand, the redside shiners HAVE almost disappeared from Strawberry. Used to be able to net a bunch of them but haven’t heard of any being caught by DWR or anglers for some time.

strawberry is a unreal fishery but in the past there has been a problem with not planting bow the right size to make it past the cuts now they are the new numbers of the bow in there is going to impact the cuts where i know i was catching large numbers of cuts i am now getting a large number of planter bows this is either pushing the cuts deeper where they will not be feeding on the chubs but on the kokness or starving them i guess time will tell but one thing is for sure the rainbow are back in larger numbers then they have been in many years and this lake is changing because of it

I sometimes think that the reason some folks catch one species at Strawberry and not the other is because of tactics. If you’re catching rainbows and want to catch cutts, change what you’re offering them. It might change what you’re catching.

“I am not against golf, since I cannot but suspect it keeps armies of the unworthy from discovering trout.”

I just gotta say I LOVE this signature quote, nice one TS30!

Oh come on now!!! You know you want Small Mouth Bass in the Berry..[sly]

And some June suckers as well…

You sure that is not a bass???

My vote has ALWAYS been for Kamloop. Nice big hard fighting Rainbows that grow super fast.

We just as well put in some Walleye as well and a few Lakers as well..[;)]

Oh yes some Sailfish as well..[sly]

I’m with you on that one..

I sometimes think that the reason some folks catch one species at Strawberry and not the other is because of tactics. If you’re catching rainbows and want to catch cutts, change what you’re offering them. It might change what you’re catching.

i guess we will see time will tell but i know this last year ive caught a dozen cuts over 26 inches so i dont think its my tactics and regardless i still want tiger in there that is reasonable unlike some requests

When I heard tigers I was thinking Tiger Muskie, I got all excited until I read further. Oh well, trout will have to do for the berry.

When I heard tigers I was thinking Tiger Muskie, I got all excited until I read further. Oh well, trout will have to do for the berry.Problem is, they just want chub reduction, not total fish reduction!

They would do a number on those chubs ha ha.

What the hell, I will sign it if you take me to the Berry and show me your tricks [;)]