petition for tiger in the berry

being that there are some tigers in there already i have caught 5 or 6 this year and that they are twice the fish in every way over the cuts looks taste and fight and i have had the discussion with some or the dwr people and was told this is the way to get them in there i have been to the berry 3 times this week and and what i see the cut are even getting push out of the places they normal live by the little bows and it wont be long before you see the chubs blow up in this lake again i havent seen it yet but im guessing the cuts are going deep and going to start seeing this take its toll on the koknee population tiger wont be pushed around by the little bow

5 or 6 Tigers? Man I fish Strawberry more than any other stillwater in Utah. I have even caught Koke on a fly, but I have never caught a Tiger.

EXACTLY !![fishin]

this is one pic you can clearly see where i’m standing and see the fish this is a small one but we have got a few different ones

well i think the tigers would do a lot better job of eating chub then the lazy cutthrouts.. thay grow a lot faster too. eat a lot better and can be controled a lot easyer too. but then i dont think anything is going to help the lake when the chub finish takeing it over!! [:p]

I would sign that 100 times if I could! The reason I don’t fish Strawberry anymore is because of all the cutthroat-shaped snags I keep reeling in. Those lethargic slimers are about as much fun to reel in as weeds and twigs. Tigers on the other hand put up a fight! Unfortunately, most of the fishermen in this state get such a kick out of landing a fish over 20" they think Strawberry is the best thing ever. Put a bunch of tigers in there and increase the slot to 25" and you’ll start seeing what that lake can really produce.

One other advantage to tigers is that they don’t take drifted baits as regularly as cutts and rainbows. They like stuff that moves, and as a result they tend to get hooked in the lip more than in the gut. With a fishery that is largely catch and release it would help immensely if more of the released fish survived to grow another day.

I would throw a party if I found out Tigers and Brookies were being planted into the berry. I would also start making plans to buy a cabin up there as I would fish no where else.

I don’t get the whole “Why mess with a good thing?” line of reasoning. The great thing with sterile fish, such as tigers and the brookies they would plant, is that they could stop planting them if things started going downhill.

I would vote to replace 1/3 of the bows they plant with tigers and then add some sterile brookies. There is no reason the Berry couldn’t turn into Henry’s south. It would be great to add a few species so that you could target individual species and not always know what you hook.

In addition, seems like some non-sterile browns could also be planted and they would maintain a healthy balance.

Can you imagine the berry with cutts, bows, tigers, brookies, browns and kokes. Freaking awesome!

I would co-host it! I honestly would love to see both brookies and tigers in there, but if I had to chose just one I have to say brook trout. If you ever get this petition going let me know I will for sure sign.

How dare you even bring up such a thing! !! [;)] god forbid we add more slimers to a cold lake like the berry that has a solid forage base like it does … you should be tarred and feathered for such a thought…[:p]

 U want my opinion.... fill the lake with Musky... haha :sunglasses: 

In before the lock!!!

When I first saw Tigers - that’s what I thought (hoped) he meant, and I said to myself, “Self, - what a great idea!”

Duckdog - kinda hard to see that trout’s coloration.
Is it a “native” [crazy]
Show me where the chubs are! I’ll bring my cast net! Git 'er done!

What lock? I’ll just wait for it…
[inline 269.jpeg]

I think you guys are on the right track here. I would LOVE to see Tiger Trout and Brookies in Strawberry. But something to think about is would the Tigers be in the slot? It does no good to not have a protective slot on them. They would have to be lumped in with the cutthroats. The key is to get this in writing and present it to the DWR then get some guys to attend a RAC meeting. I wonder what the DWR will think of the idea? To me it sounds really good.

dwr responce

We are actually working on a survey to decide some of the future management directions for Strawberry. And though a petition may help bolster some support for such a cause, unfortunately petitions do not get much of the needed information out to the public. I think we have discussed this with you in the past, we have a few concerns with what you are suggesting that I will reiterate.

First of all, we have limited production in our hatcheries, and with shrinking budgets and recent state audits, production will become more limited. Therefore we cannot increase production to add a species to our current stocking quotas.

Also, the cutthroat have proven to do a great job at keeping chubs under control, we cannot switch that program to another species at this point. Tigers have not proven that they can do the same job on chubs. The tigers in Scofield have not yet shown that they can do the same job. In addition, the tigers are not as easily caught by anglers. One of our many goals at Strawberry is to provide a fishery where people can expect high catch rates, and our experience at other reservoirs is that tigers do not provide this. Yes, many anglers do figure out how to catch them, but the average angler does not catch many. We also get a considerable amount of natural reproduction from the cutthroat (35% of our cutthroat population on average), and we would get none from the tigers. Basically we would have fewer fish in the reservoir as a result of switching cutthroat for tigers, again making chub control more difficult with tigers. We closely monitor the fish in Strawberry every year, and our cutthroat are looking great as far as condition, fat levels, and growth. Cutthroat often look skinny compared to some other fish, but that is how they naturally grow until they get to larger sizes when they put on more girth. Increasing in length faster than they put on girth is their strategy to become a more effective predator, and it works. However, you may have noticed that cutthroat numbers have declined somewhat in the last couple of years, and is due to a couple of year classes of stocked fish not surviving well. These stocked fish came in undersized, and many were eaten. Cutthroat numbers should be on the rebound over the next couple of years, and we need them for chub control.

One possibility would be to switch rainbow production for tigers. However, based on angler opinion surveys we regularly do at Strawberry, I do not think this would be a popular option. Most anglers want more rainbows, not fewer, or none if we made the switch. If angler opinion did show that they wanted tigers instead of rainbows, we could consider that option. However, in any king of survey or petition it would be necessary that the anglers were aware that they would be giving up rainbows to get the tigers.

As far as kokanee, there is not much to bargain with there. We only raise a few thousand pounds of kokanee (compared to 100,000 lbs of cutthroat and rainbows), and that would not be enough to stock the numbers of tigers we would need to show up in the creel.

Again, a petition would help gain some interest and support for such a change, but we have to look at the broader picture as well. We could not make any such changes unless there was considerable evidence that the switch would work for us biologically (chub control, and other such factors), would provide the desired fishery (high catch rates), is cost effective from a production standpoint, and is what the majority of the angling public wants (would need to be determined from a broader scale angler survey).

I hope this helps clarify our current position on this. And by no means am I anti-tigers (or anti- most fish species for that matter). They all have their place. Thanks for letting me comment.

Alan Ward
Strawberry Project Leader
Utah Division of Wildlife Resources

This is the response i got to the e-mail i sent to Alan Ward so what i get out of this is there is hope but we have to have to get a lot of in put and they would take a way for the bow numbers being planted and i’m guessing that they would still fall into the cut slot limit still i say bring them on !!!

A couple of comments;

1.RE " It is being done because of the the Endangered Species Act. And that is the core reason for Bear Lake Cutthroats being in Strawberry."

There were 2 core reasons. One was to control the chubs. In spite of occasional whining to the contrary, the solid evidence is that they are doing very well at that. The second was to provide a **reserve **population of BL cutts. Keep in mind, the BL cutt is a nonnative strain to the Strawberry drainage. Since the DWR has also stocked BL cutts in Panguitch, Scofield and other fisheries, the importance of Strawberry as a reserve population goes down as there are now several such population groups. The USFWS may not be as strict with Strawberry and sterile frankenfish as they would Utah lake and the native June sucker.

  1. Brookies; Yeah, I admit that brookies would be fun, but can you guarantee that the brookies stocked are 100% sterile? (and I assume you guys are proposing sterile brookies) If they became established, there is always a chance that they could upset the current decent balance we see there. Therefore, I doubt you’d see them be approved especially compared to the 100% sterile tigers.

  2. Browns; I have seen I reliable pic of a brown caught out of there in the past 7 years. There are already probably a few there.

Again, say what you want about the cutts, but the place is pretty amazing right now for both numbers and size, and the bows are now coming on too. I am fine keeping it that way. I suppose it is human nature to think the grass is always greener if things were different.

Oops, almost forgot, In before the lock, but this one probably won’t get locked. [;)]

Thanks for posting up the biologists response. Good stuff.

like none of the bow are spawning in there now this fish was caught the same day as that tiger and we got 4 or 5 of them from horse creek to the ladder where is pic was taken

The presence of eggs or milt does not indicate that the fish are able to reproduce. Only that they are able to produce eggs or milt. The process of producing triploids renders those eggs useless.

Didn’t TD mention, that just because there are eggs, doesn’t mean they are reproducing? I know HUMAN women this is true​:blush:

true but when you catch 50 fish that apear to be female and no eggs then you get only 4 or 5 with it makes it look like a few may have been missed and we did get one fish that looked clearly like a bear lake cut rainbow cross wish i would of got a pic of that fish

Man I wasn’t expecting such a negative response from the DWR. Hate to tell you guys that want Tigers in there but we are now toast. Without the DWR being on board we are really toast. Bad deal here because I would have liked, no loved, to see Tigers in Strawberry. But man the DWR loves and loves the hatchery rainbows. They don’t want anything to get in the way of dumping a few million planter rainbows in there. Too bad, but this issue is over. Wet blanket over a nice fire we had going. Utah DWR loves the slay 'em then fillet 'em crowd and will give in to them every dang time.

true but when you catch 50 fish that apear to be female and no eggs then you get only 4 or 5 with it makes it look like a few may have been missed and we did get one fish that looked clearly like a bear lake cut rainbow cross wish i would of got a pic of that fish

:sunglasses:There are two words we should never use…especially when talking about fishing…and especially in Utah. NEVER & ALWAYS.


**When the rainbows are treated at the hatchery to make them “triploids”…with three of the genetic chromosomes instead of only one (normal)…it renders them sterile. That doesn’t mean that they cannot produce eggs or milt…just that they are “shooting blanks”. It also does not mean that all fish will or won’t produce eggs or milt. Some do and some don’t. It is possible to catch rainbows from the same hatchery batchery in which some do exhibit spawn readiness and others do not. No always and no never. The closest we come to never is that the fish that do produce eggs and milt will not produce offspring…even if they go through all the right spawning motions. **


SO…just because a fish has eggs or milt does not mean they are “natives”…or that they are capable of producing offspring.


**Also…what “looks clearly” like a cuttbow means nothing. Both rainbows and cutts are subject to wide variations in coloration…among the same species and among the same hatchery output. It takes a trained biologist and sometimes DNA testing to verify a true cross. **


Cutts do Spawn naturally in Strawberry…but in the early summer. Rainbows typically spawn in early spring…and some in late fall. There is at least a two to three month gap between potential meetings of the milt and eggs of cutts and bows…and since the bows are not fertile anyway…welllllll.


Can’t say it could NEVER happen. But it is highly unlikely.


If you really want to verify species based upon a quick observation, you really do need to take a series of pictures clearly showing not only the fish but closeups of the head, tail, spotting patterns and anything else that might help in making an identification from a picture. Otherwise, the only real ID can only be made by a trained biologist.

well they did kill all the chubs so the must of got all the rainbows to