Hey Bigcat,
I have been pondering this very issue since I heard the news of the 2 pole permit going into effect at the end of this year.
At first, I also was excited because I get the 2 pole permit every year. For the last few weeks, I have been working on solutions and testing out some of my ideas to that end. I’ve come up with several prototypes that address this - mostly based on my bank fishing experience.
My answer so far is PVC. And, the alpha testing has proven to be quite promising. If an 8 pound catfish or a 10 pound carp can’t drag my rig down the drink, I figure one of those little 3-6 pound Strawberry cutts won’t be able to either.
In the past, I only used some cheapo ice rod holders that I got because they were light, compact and handy.
But, even then, I never had a cutt drag my rig down the hole. When a cutt hit my jig, it just bent the rod a little and slid the holder a few inches before I got to it and found out that I had just missed another fish because I wasn’t either paying attention, or, I wasn’t fast enough.
That said, I do know of people who have lost a rig to the depths because a fish made off with it.
However, as I designed and tested my ideas, it occurred to me, that I might be actually looking at the problem all wrong.
Traditionally, in my case, ice fishing has been jigging. Jigging is an active method of fishing for me. Yes, I do dead stick on occassion, but that is a minor part of the activity for me.
I jig by feel, sometimes by watching my line move where it enters the water, but not by waiting for my line to start peeling off - Mostly, I jig by feel.
It also occurred to me in the process, that even though, I have always gotten a 2 pole permit, and I have ice fished on bodies of water like Utah Lake, Willard, etc., where it was permitted, I’ve always only used one rod.
Additionally, at Strawberry, it has been my experience, that if I miss the initial hit from the fish and don’t get a hook set right away, , the fish usually spits out the jig and is gone.
For me, rarely has one of those nice cutts hooked itself on an unattended line and stayed there long enough for me to actually bring it to the ice or the boat.
Yes, it does happen, and that is why I am still working on setting up a true beta test for my new rod holders. Plus, it will give me more chances to try other riggings and methods while ice fishing - like surface floats and weighted bottom floaters.
But, knowing me, I will probably only use my prototype when I need to put my rod down to do one of those other things that a person needs to attend to.
I guess my take on the situation right now would be this - using 2 poles will probably mean - missing twice as many fish and only catching half as many.
But, even so, I can’t wait to see what I do when I have the opportunity to watch my second pole getting tugged towards one of my soon to be required 3 ice holes, while I am already fighting a fish on my first rod in the one adjacent hole that does not have a fish finder in it.