Thanks, Mister. Glad you approve. You make some good “points” on trebles. While some lures come with high quality hooks and split rings, others should be replaced before you ever put the lure in the water. Like yourself, I have had some PREVENTABLE misfortunes by not making sure the hardware would hold up to the type of fishing I was doing.
**Like all fishermen, I have my own opinions about which hooks are best. I have been making and “tuning up” lures for many years, and I think I have tried just about everything at least once. **
**Again, like most anglers, I would like to be able to afford to have Gamakatsu trebles on all my lures. They are the quality standard of the industry. They are made of quality steel and they are one of the few hooks that come out of the package sharp enough to use without working them over with a sharpener. You can find them in many sizes and styles…including some already “dressed” with feathers. **
That being said, I usually do not buy Gamakatsus. I get good service from the mostly Eagle Claw, Mustad and VMC hooks I use most, and at a far lower price. I have several plastic boxes with assorted trebles, in different sizes, strengths and materials (bronze and nickle). For a good source for almost any kind of treble, go to BARLOW’S TACKLE . They have pics and descriptions of all of the hooks I will mention below.
**For most lures, in small to medium sizes, I use either the bronze VMC 9449 BZ, the nickle version (9649 N), or Eagle Claw 374 (bronze) or 375 (nickle). Most of the dressed trebles in the pics are Eagle Claw 375. **
Actually, those Eagle Claw hooks are rated as 2X strong, so I also use them up to the 1/0 size for stripers and salt water too. Never had one break or bend, but I do not use “hawser cable” line, and if I hook a “terminal” snag, my line will break before the hook will bend. At least I have never had a big fish bend or break one of them.
It may be purely a personal preference or cosmetic thing, but I like the curved (beak) points on the Eagle Claw trebles too. Once you get a good “working” point on the hooks, they bite in easy and hold well. They also put holes in my fingers when I am trying to dress them up with hair or feathers.
Mustad has a good line of “workhorse” trebles too. They are inexpensive and are often the hooks that come standard on the lures we buy. Cheaper models usually bend more easily, and should be tested before you throw them at fish. But, for “average” fishing conditions, and for fish that are not likely to damage your gear, you can leave them on if you like.
Like most manufacturers, Mustad does make stronger hooks…2X strong. Sportsmans sells those I think. They are in the same price range as Eagle Claws, so it is a matter of personal choice.
VMC trebles have a slightly shorter hook shank than the Eagle Claws. They are lighter wire and the hooks are usually pretty sharp, right out of the package. They are a good choice for many lures and they are also competitive with Eagle Claws and Mustads in price, for similar size and finish.
How much should you pay for trebles? I have always gone by the expression “It is better to pay a little more than you wanted to…than not quite enough.” Hooks are the final connection between you and a fish. They are equally important to maintaining good quality fresh line on your reel.
The good news is that decent hooks are not THAT expensive. Sure, Gamakatsu trebles will run from about 50 cents to almost $1.50 each…and they are often worth the extra expense. However, if you make and use a lot of lures, and want the most bang for the buck, most of the other models mentioned will cost under 20 cents apiece…depending on how you buy them.
I probably use more of the Eagle Claw 375 (nickle) than any other trebles. I buy them in packs of 50 hooks, usually for under $8.50 per pack. That works out to about 17 cents apiece. They are 2X strong, but have decent points that only require a little touch with the hone before fishing. Since I fish a lot of lures in whites and silvers, the nickle hooks add flash. But, for ice spoons, blade baits and many spinners, I will use the bronze models…expecially if I am covering the hooks with “dressing” and/or bait.
And, don’t forget to use good split rings.