What Does Strawberry Need?

Poor choice of words for a student that should be broadening their horizons and be open minded about different opinions and views.

If you think transplanting chubs would solve both problems lets here why. Their is many different factors you need to consider before you make a judgement like cost, disease, time, short and long term effects on both ecosystems.

I know this might be a little of topic but since your so adamant about helping a certain fishery why don’t you tell us what you have done for any fishery?

Hey what about a chub party?[sly] Dont know what we’d do with all the chubs though. It could’nt be that bad though to have a chub party and hey, who knows maybe you’ll lay into a couple of fat trout![;)] Not gonna solve the problem but at least you can say that you’ve contributed to the effort of saving the place! And feel good about it. As for the crawfish. Bring em’ to my place. I’ll eat em till I burst.

One reason that Utah has such a chub problem is because many people think that they can just move fish around to wherever they want. Whether it is because they think that a live fish is a superior bait, or because they think it will provide a better forage fish, or just because they want another sport fish. Don’t expect the DWR to ever purposefully introduce chubs into a sportfishery water. That is just ludicrous! That would never solve the problem at Starvation. It would cause you to have another problem just like Strawberry. One of the big problems with Strawberry is it is that the fish are taken out before they get to a big enough size to start eating chubs. The DWR can’t up the slot limit on all trout, because there are way too many people that want to be able to take fish home. Strawberry is the most heavily fished lake in Utah, which means the DWR has to attempt to balance too many variables. How do you grow fish large enough to keep the chubs in balance, while at the same time satisfy over 1 million angler hours with fish to take home to eat?

What makes strawberry so great is also what makes it have the tendency to grow trash fish. It has tons of food and a cool enough temperature to hold enough oxygen for an amazing amount of fish. If the trout do not fill the resivoirs food and oxygen capicity other fish will. I personally vote they simply change the limit to one trout over 25". That would of course mean very limited harvest for the next 2 years but hey we went through it when they poisoned it. This time we could have an amazing fishery within two years and could still fish it in the mean time so long as we could live without having the freezer full. Long term I don’t know a fisherman around that wouldn’t be happy catching 10 fish a day in the 20+ range and then taking one home at 25". We could have killer action on real trophies and still take home enough fish meat. At 25" those babies are heavy and have very thick fillets.

As for long term income. Think of the dollars a fishery like that would bring in. And you could still take a kid out and let him catch fish.

Sometimes good things comes with just a tiny bit of patience. Something the average fisherman doesn’t have.

I’m not in favor that chubs be moved from Strawberry to Starvation, because for one reason it would be expensive and would only temporarily solve the problem. However, be aware that there have been chubs in Starvation for many years, and the reason that the DWR gillnetted the walleye out there for a couple years was to give the chubs a chance to survive (the average age of a chub out there is approximately20 years old!) so that they could reproduce and provide forage for the walleye, bass and brown trout. After they discovered that someone had illegally planted perch out there they abandoned the gillnetting because the perch would also be a predator for the newly hatched chubs, so it was useless to net the walleye any longer.

Great point PBH! A voice of reason was really needed here. I hope that we can all discuss things such as this without resorting to insulting each other. We all want the same thing…great fishing, so lets work together to find a solution, not to prove who is right. Just my 2 cents.

actually PBH…the DWR would love to have a hatchery or some way to get some more chubs into Starvation. Utah chubs ARE the forage base there and the walleyes and smallmouths have totally decimated that base. I remember a few years back I heard that the DWR was actually considering setting up a temporary hatchery to raise chubs just for Starvation.(Don’t know if it was actually true) From what I heard, the cost just proved to be too much.

Also, lets not forget that the Utah chub is one of the only native fish to Utah. That’s another reason it is so prevalent in our waters.

I love this interactive forum. I think all of you are on the right track. The fact that you care enough to look for solutions is very positive. FYI Nobody needs to contact TomP, or the DWR for suggestions. I guarantee they are following most of these posts on BFT on a regular basis. Any professionals reading this that care to add their $.02 on Strawberry?. Come on, speak up. We know you’re out there. LMAO.

Good Lurking, Kayote

As I love to read a good debate. Lets leave the childish name calling and insults out of it. Debate till ya’ll are blue in the face. Anymore insults and prepare to be eighty sixed.

i say stock sauger everywhere and anywhere, then Utah can be the sauger capital of the world! the trouble is we have too many people that like to catch too many kinds of fish - my answer - SAUGER FOR EVERYONE!

:face_with_tongue:

sm

I think the answer to Strawberry’s chub problem is simple,just let the big fish go.I have fished Strawberry for years,and people are just too short sighted to see that.Now we have the new regs

You really are not sure what your talking about, are you. Starvation is filled with Bass and Walleye, and they can acctually controll the chubs. So much, in fact that they are wipping out the smaller chubs, so none of them are surviving to reach the age of reproduction. If you dumped more chubs into Starvation, and took from the thriving population at Strawberry, you would be helping the Walleyes and Bass at Starvation, which are becoming smaller and smaller because of there being little or no bait fish that they can eat. Also, the fact that they are chubs that they are eating out at Starvation would prove that they need more chubs. Now, if you don’t like that, keep it to yourself. You obviously do not know what you are talking about, so you should not critize other people. And yes, if you can get away with it, live minnows are a far supperior bait to their dead counter parts. Fish for Ling Cod in Oregon with jigs, then go to Washington and fish with Perch. You’ll see the difference the first minute that you drop down.

Hey JensenKid15…I think those threats of being eighty-sixed were meant for you.

Lets keep the tones of our posts respectful!

Ok Jensenkid, say they took all the chubs out of strawberry and put them in Starvation. All the Bass and walleyes would pig them selfs out, get all fat, and maybe they would have a good spawn in the spring, but after a year or 2 almost all the chubs that they had planted will have been eatin up, leaving a bunch of dieing starving fish, just like where were at now, in the long run nothing will have come out of moveing all the chubs except alot of wasted time, money, and effort. just my $.02 worth

Hey Jensenkid you forgot to answer my question so I’ll add another to it.

What makes you such a expert on this?

What have you done to improve any fishery?

By the way what level of education are you?

Quote- “if you can get away with it”

This isn’t the message a true sportsmen would broadcast to fellow sportsmen.

Big problem with Starvation is the predator vs. prey ratio. There are way too many predators and not enough prey (basically, there are too many fish and not enough food). So, how do you fix this? By adding more fish? Adding chubs to starvation isn’t going to do it. We already know that Starvation has chubs. So, why add more? Especially since we have already seen that the chubs aren’t going to be able to put up with predation of the other fish. The solution is what the DWR is already asking fishermen to do. Remove more predators, so that the chubs can reproduce. It’s no different than any other game management. It’s obvious that Starvation has too many predators. Adding more prey will not help. The number of predators needs to be reduced to balance what the prey can thrive at. One way to fix this is to let Mother Nature take her course.

If you really enjoy fishing with live minnows in Utah, you really need to pull your head out! I can’t tell you how many lakes in this state have been ruined, and how much money the state has had to spend to remove trash fish due to illegal introduction of fish by fishermen. If you want to use live bait, then go fish for your Ling Cod in Oregon. Or, better yet, go catch some Yellowtail, Albacore, and Tuna. But don’t be using it in Utah. You don’t need it in this state – dead works just as good.

Just before they killed off Strawberry the last time. I fished with almost exclusively whole med sized chubs. And caught more big fish that year than any other in my life. The problem is not that the Cutts won’t eat enough rough fish or that they aren’t aggressive enough. The problem is that we don’t let them hit there glorious 10# potential which most every trout in Strawberry would hit if we just let them. I can assure you a 10# Cutt will eat plenty of Chubs. It could get to be like Bear Lake, or Flaming Gorge, or Starvation. Where we wish there were more chubs because the fish are getting thin simply because they have eaten all the chubs.

Why do you think everyone on here is always talking about using minnows at the Berry. It is because Cutt’s like other fish. We just need to let them get big enough to eat full sized chubs and let there numbers be large enough to eat more than are being produced each year. It’s not that difficult it just takes a little patience to let nature balance itself out.

tightline

UTBass,

I have to respectfully disagree on the Starvation structure comment. I have fished Starvation a lot for many years and the whole reservoir is structure. From the rocks that surround almost the entire lake to the vast weedbeds that are there at any water level in the Strawberry arm, Rabbit Gulch and Saleratus. Maybe I’m misunderstanding your structure comment?

Good Fishing, Kayote

PS In the words of the infamous Rodney King “Can’t we all just get along”?. LMAO

I will say right now that I am sorry for any ignorance that I may have put onto this site. That really is just the way that I am. For the live minnows, you got the wrong idea. I have never used them, never will. When I was in Washington a few years ago, I put down live Perch and Greenling, and caught some good sized Ling Cod on them. That is why I said that live fish are sometimes supperior to dead. I have never used them in Utah, and I never will. As for Strawberry, one other thing that might work is to put Splake in there. The fish at Joe’s Valley have done pretty good so far at controlling the chubs. It is in my personal oppinion, however, that the Cutts will not do the job. The DWR will do what they will do, and I will support them all the way. I just figured that if you could help 2 lakes, rather than 1, it would work out best. However, if there is no backing for this kind of a plan I’ll just quit while I’m ahead. I really am sorry for any name calling I may have done. Thanks.

Jerry Jensen, the kid.

That’s cool Jensen, it takes a big man to admit something like that and apologize. I think I speak for everyone here when I say all’s well that ends well. [sly]