We are looking to do a fall tournament for the tiger musky. We will keep everyone informed.
clif clif clif cant you just leave well enough alone?
Sorry you can’t see what or why I ask…
First when we was trying to get weigh-in tournaments most that was against it was saying we would kill too many fish…Now we have some one like you and what you are hinting at…I don’t like tournaments that kill fish, no one should like them…
Why have a tournament that you measure and take a picture of the fish then kill it…
Most walleye and bass and Muske tournaments take points away if you kill fish…
Clif we arent like most tournaments. We arent like most clubs.
I want our tournaments to stay the same that they are right now cause its more like a bunch of buddies out there fishing and throwing money in a hat than a tournament. Tournaments get ugly in your world. I dont want that.
If you are out fishing with your buddy and he wants to eat some walleye that he caught are you going to cry then too? Is state law going to prevent him from taking them home?
And like I stated before 97 percent of the fish caught during this particular tounament went back in the drink. Thats considerably less than if these were all a bunch of friends out fishing for the day. Most chucked them back in BECAUSE of the tournament. I know for a fact that guys had been pulling eyes to eat all week long. I’m not ashamed to say that for the tournament they did the exact opposite. I’m proud of them. And they aught to be rpoud too.
I ask you a question..You gave me your answer… Then some one makes it out like I should not have ask it, I didn’t say anything about you or how you run your tournament so why are you coming at me…
I wasnt “coming at you”. I was clarifying why I run things the way I do with you so you didnt think I just jumped back and forth on stuff.
I can see your point, but if you don’t turn the fish back from a tournament you may start having some and no fish will be caught…Each person that enters a tournament must go by tournament rules or not fish them as long as they are with in state laws so if the tournament says letem go that is what all must do..
Our rules state exactly this “CATCH and RELEASE is recommended”
Isn’t the DWR encouraging some harvest walleyes out of Starvation, due to high population density?
I know I’m going to eat some out of there this year. I’d like to get up there soon but this thing called work keeps getting in the way. I need to put in some more hours to pay for the next thing that breaks on the boat ha ha ha.
Wish I was there as it sounds like a great time was had by all.
I dont remember them mentioning anything about it, but my head is still running after taht day so it doesnt mean they didnt say anything about it.
I think you’re putting too much thought in to this. If someone catches a fish and wants to keep it, that’s his right. Ratstar clearly stated that the club encourages catch and release, that’s not a tournament rule, just a suggestion.
I don’t understand why you think catch and release is the only way to fish. Starvation is doing good for walleye right now, it doesn’t make them any easier to catch but if you catch a walleye or two and keep them it’s not going to affect the entire balance of the ecosystem. People fish for food, I love to eat walleye, perch, and starvation and gorge smallies.
Tournament anglers should be the least of your worry about keeping fish. If they do keep fish they are well within the law.
If you are so passionate about the effects of keeping fish you should go to school and become a biologist (English 99 first) or become a DWR officer and police the real world instead of this forum.
Edit: I am sorry ratstar, only replying to a previous post. Don’t get this post locked, send a pm if you want to reply to me.
Harvesting walleye, especially smaller fish, from Starvation will only benefit the fishery.
amen!!! I kept some smaller ones. I almost always do. They need to be thinned out a little unless we want a crash to happen.
Could you post the actual amounts that were awarded for 1st, 2nd, & 3rd places & big fish. You stated the wining angler got somewhere around $800 bucks. Did this include the big fish money as well which he also took? At the tourney you stated there were 48 entrants. Based on the rules of a 75% payout and first place getting 32.5% of that the winner should have gotten $877.50 just for first place not counting the big fish money. It was windy during the awards and my hearing isn’t as good as it once was, but I’m not sure that was the number I heard stated when he recieved his cash. Would really give you guys some credibility if you would post the actual numbers of entrants and payouts.
Maybe I misunderstood the rules as they were printed. When you were announcing the results you stated there were 48 entries. If there were 40 entrants as stated that would be:
40 x $75 = $3,000.00
75% payout would equal a total of $2,250.00 prize money.
The rules stated 1st place would recieve 32.5% of that which should be $731.50 for 1st place and then another $225.00 for big fish which means Shaun should have recieved a total payout of $956.25.
Based on the numbers you proveded it looks like Shaun was shorted about $244.25.
These numbers just don’t add up so if you could be so kind as to review the accounting and correct me if I’m wrong or didn’t understand the rules it would be appreciated. If I am in fact not wrong I would like to see that you send Shaun and the others the correct amounts for their winnings.
Based on the numbers you provided your total payout was only $1,500 when it should have been a total of at least $2,250.
40 x $75 = $3,000.00 x .75%= $2,250.00 ![]()
In fact your numbers are wrong. We had quite a few members fish this tournament ($50 entry fee) along side the non members ($75 entry fee).
I will post the numbers as soon as I get a chance, as I am at work right now and dont have any of my papers in front of me. I will say that if we did short anyone, the problem will be corrected. Seeing as we run the numbers before the tournament to give us an idea, it ALWAYS ends up different from those that actually show up, we do have a margin of error simply because we are human.
I will post exact numbers asap. I also will be posting the exact point standings soon, but due to work keeping me so late this week, I have not quite finished them yet, sorry for the delay.
I think providing that level of detail and transparency would really help allot to build your creditbility. Like you said, any time money is involved things get ugly especially if all the numbers aren’t out there for everyone to see. There is a natural dis-trust.
We are actually quit the opposite than most. Like I explained to bassrods, we arent your normal club. And we sure arent your normal tournaments. We’ve been as open as possible right now and will continue to be that way. Regardless of all the natural distrust going around we have found one of the greatest group of guys and we intend to keep it that way.
I appreciate people such as yourself, pointerpride, and bassrods trying to find holes in our club/tourney runnings, for those people who may have had the same questions and not brought them up. **Again all of this is in the Rules and Regulations packet we give every angler to sign. **So we are pretty see though there too.
First off the numbers:
40 people x $50 entry per person for tournament cash specifically* = $2000
Non-members do pay an extra $25 dollars, but this goes into our fishing habitat fund (kind of keeps that money growing on top of the normal donations) great way to get people to donate. We call this the Temporary Membership Fee. Every non member must pay this.
So running the numbers with the $2000 here is the break down exactly:
75% of $2000 = $1500 the other $500 goes towards the year long tournament for points standings of which every person who fishes our tournaments is entered in.
First Place = 32.5% = $487.50
Second Place = 25% = $375
Third Place = 17.5% = $262.50
Longest Walleye = 15% = $225
Longest Bass = 10% = 150
487.50+375+262.50+225+150=$1500
*Tournament cash cannot exceed $2000 handed out that day unless we get a permit and pay the state. We keep it this way cause the state makes enough of our hard earned money. Simply put we want to give back maximum amount possible.
Any other questions at this time?
Thanks for clarifying. There were allot of questions regarding the numbers which is why I decided to ask. I apologize if my questions sounded accusatory.
One thing I think would really help minimize these type questions and add a very high level of transparency in the future and would be if you could publish a spread sheet after each tourney detailing things like:
Number of member entrants:
Number of non-member entrants:
Total income for the tournement:
Total $ for temporary membership going to habitat fund:
75% total and break down of the payout:
Total of the 25% $ going towards the season points:
Total $ in the habitat fund:
Total $ in the season points pot:
Finally, I know you’ve stated you’re doing this for the love of the sport. Putting together these types of tournements takes allot of time and effort on your part. I’m sure you must have some expenses involved as well. I think it would be reasonable for you to get a percentage of the income to offset this. Most professionally run tournements are not pro-bono.