Ok, I’ll jump in on this one. Your story sounds similar to mine. My family was camping at Strawberry every year and fishing from shore. I wanted to get a boat to get out on the lake. I ended up getting two little aluminum ones, a 14’ and a 12’. They were both fine within the bays and in good weather. However, the Strawberry wind is notorious for kicking up about 11:00am daily and you pretty much need to find a little hole to hide in for a few hours or get off the lake. It is even scarier if you have kids in the boat with you.
I usually fished chicken creek. We went out to that island at the mouth one time, the wind came out of nowhere, and the waves were climbing the back of the boat as we tried to make it back, they were outrunning what our little motor could put out.
One other drawback to the little ones is comfort. You can sure get a sore back sitting there for a couple of hours, even if you add the little seats. It’s difficult to stand and stretch if there is any weather.
That only lasted me a year, then I went and got my first “real” boat, a 17.5’ tri-hull with a 135hp outboard. I paid $2k for it and it was amazing the difference. I could fish the whole lake, caught a lot more fish, wasn’t afraid to have kids with if there was wind, usually, and could move around quickly if the wind came up.
The drawback is that the tri-hulls don’t handle the large waves well. They climb and drop with them, which can be dangerous in bigger waves.
I used that little boat for 5 years and really loved it. This last year we upgraded to a 19’ Deep V hull with a 305 v8 I/O. It is MUCH, MUCH better. I was in the middle of the lake in some really nasty waves and it cut through them just great. I would have feared for my life on that tri-hull.
With all of that said, I would STRONGLY suggest putting that $2500 toward a larger used boat. Especially where you are going to have kids with you.
One other bonus is that many of the used ones come with a lot of the extras you will end up forking over another $1k for: life jackets, electronics, pole holders, sometimes downriggers, etc, etc, etc.
We just went through this whole long discussion with another person looking for their first boat. Look at the ‘boat help’ thread near the top of the off topic board. There is a LOT of great info there. He found himself what looks to be a really nice boat for just $3500. Go read through the info on that thread before making your decision. 