rigid pontoon/ kickboat question??

when you said that was not sure you meant before or after you poked the hole in the toon.. :-).. now I know.. :slight_smile:

MacFly :sunglasses:

I’m glad you understand now. haha

The next time you are tubing in the middle of winter months and get a slow leak in your tube, try making an equal size pin hole in your waders and see if you can still concentrate on the leak in the tube. haha.:sunglasses:

without my waders getting wet.. aint gonna happen.. [sly]

MacFly :sunglasses:

This is the pontoon I am getting, Venture Outdoors Colorado Dura Pro 10’ Pontoon Boat. I can’t find any reviews on it though. They say this thing can handle class III water and can hold up to 450lbs., which tells me it is the toughest one out there. Has anyone ever bought one of these things. And what is up with everbody selling pontoonboats for $100-$200 more than Wal-Mart. You really have to shop around or you are going to be mad later when you find out how much you overpaid. Even Venture sells the same pontoon I am getting for $100 more than Wally world (Wal-Mart), and they are the ones making them. Any opinions on the pontoon I am looking at would be greatly appreciated, and I will post once I get it.

I have a Venture Outdoors Pontoon. I bought it straight from Carol Olsen.
I bought the 4’ Echo at the time because that is what I was looking for.
She told me she was getting a Walmart contract going. They sell the Echo also for about half what I paid. BUT, it is NOT the same boat.
First off, mine has the self sealing bladder, but can be slightly deflated.
Walmart version is solid:

Walmart’s Echo

My Echo:

Mine has pontoon covers and the frame is apparently different as I can see it on the side of mine but not in the Walmart version.

They are Fantastic BULLET PROOF pontoons, but don’t be surprised if you $100. more one is not the same as Walmart’s

One thing about buying from Wal mart, is you can always return almost anything because of their customer satisfaction. Also you save shipping charges if it is sent to the closest store for pickup instead of your own address. I did that awhile back with the Venture Echo hard pontoon model pictured below in another post. I liked the compact nature of the Echo but my butt would sit in the water, which really affects comfort and mobility, so it wasn’t for me.

I believe the Venture frames are still made in USA, whereas at least some well known American brand manufacturers are more recently contracting out to China. The ODC 616 seemed to be a low end China built version which I liked anyway because it was $100 and it kept my butt out of the water. I replaced the nylon air mattress bladder pontoons with 6’ quality clearanced priced Versa-vessel PVC available from the Versa website. The frame seems thin but seemed to take indirect stress in some class II rapids and is light and compact for travel. My outcast 7’ quad tube oncilla was also built in China and has a very heavy frame and super comfortable seat and great stability and seating position. Oncilla is one of my favorite home boats, a very good all day boat with great stability, very low draft and high quality everywhere, but not for travel at 60 # +. So I quess quality varies from poor to excellent for any particular model and brand is what I am thinking. You just have to try them out, and Walmart is a great way to do that as they refund everything if you are not satisfied. So I will be looking for your report on the Colorado in the future, thanks.

I hope this rambling story isn’t taken in the wrong way and is of some interest and help to someone. This is a great website with some great tips that I will be incorporating in the future.

Pon

This is the pontoon I am getting, Venture Outdoors Colorado Dura Pro 10’ Pontoon Boat. I can’t find any reviews on it though. They say this thing can handle class III water and can hold up to 450lbs., which tells me it is the toughest one out there. Has anyone ever bought one of these things. And what is up with everbody selling pontoonboats for $100-$200 more than Wal-Mart. You really have to shop around or you are going to be mad later when you find out how much you overpaid. Even Venture sells the same pontoon I am getting for $100 more than Wally world (Wal-Mart), and they are the ones making them. Any opinions on the pontoon I am looking at would be greatly appreciated, and I will post once I get it.

when you used the venture echo perma (hard shell model).. how low did you sit in the water.. and what.. if anything did you do to try to get the backside out of the water?? and how did it handle and track etc.. ??

MacFly

It is no different that a V tube. Your rear is SLIGHTLY in the water. Enough you need at least waist high waders. Bigger footprint, but as I said, no difference that a V and you all know how they move:sunglasses:
As far as I know, they are USA made and that little frame can be modified with foot pegs for rowing, and rear decks. Plus as Pontoon said, you can add larger toons in the future.
The molded plastic seats are the most comfortable to me but you do need to ad padding like maybe those foam hunting seats. Plus they have straps on the back you you can tilt them back.
I am betting TD would love that seat[angelic] Have to let you try one some time.
Here is my Hubby, 6’3" and 225lb.

and here is the rear deck we made plus the straps on the back of the seat

when you used the venture echo perma (hard shell model).. how low did you sit in the water.. I am 6ft 1in and 180# and felt I was down about like the pictures flygoddess sent of her husband, so the solid pontoons must be slightly smaller than her version’s inflatables. Didn’t take pictures though.

and what.. if anything did you do to try to get the backside out of the water?? **Not much, since there wasn’t enough buoyancy to work with existing pontoons. I could have built a separate simple flat frame and placed on top to get out of water, but then I would be sitting too high in a very unstable position especially with the short 4’ lengths. The only parts I could use would be the seat and pontoons which are very thin guage material. I couldn’t see any way to use the metal frame with any other pontoons not having the same diameter pontoons which is a rare size in 8’ length. **and how did it handle and track etc.. ?? **I didn’t study extensively but definately not good compared to my other boats, hydrodynamics of a flying brick because of blunt ends. May be OK with fins at 0.5 knots max, probably unstable at high speed or fast currents. I have a '94 J W outfitters osprey flat frame trampoline seat fitted to ‘96 Buck’s bag cutter 6’ super streamlined pontoons with no rocker. Fastest, lightest, most energy efficient boat anywhere in my humble estimation, 2.5 knots with 25 watt input using a prop. **

Hope this helps.

MacFly

The toons are the same size on the solid and the perma, as Mac pointed out to me. Actually a flat frame made a little wider could do the trick. The width for stability and with something like 12" diameter toons, that would still keep you close enough to kick. That is the width of my big pontoon toons and it has the flat frame. But you are right, they are rated low as far as weight capacity (200).
But, actually, just the seat of my hubby gets wet. I could probably get away with hippers.

As far as frames, Aluminum is light and need a special welder. Mine is steel, she didn’t have aluminum then and this frame is every bit as strong as the big boats. Plus a custom YELLOW powder coat.

It does have blunt ends but they sweep up. It is very mobil and can scoot.
I have been out in it during some ruff water and it was very stable and cut through the water just fine. In fact I think I get more wet from my H3 in choppy water.

If you take a look at Denny Rickard’s choice the Super Cat, it too has more or less a blunt end, just rounded off and no sweep up, but people swear by this boat. I have seen Denny fly in that boat.

yes it does.. thank you :slight_smile:

One other note about Wallys World. They do sell many top name brand items but…they are usually the inferior grade of the same product that is more expensive elsewhere.

For a few dollars more, you can get the better quality version of most of their fishing items from somewhere else.:sunglasses:

The toons are the same size on the solid and the perma, as Mac pointed out to me. I don’t know anything about the inflation pressure setup of **the perma. On my smallest toons there can be up to a 2" difference in float level above surface of water with temperature changes as this affects inflation pressure and size of the pontoon. Go in at 3# and drops down to maybe 2# due to water cooling. Don’t think this is a big factor for very large pontoons, though. **Actually a flat frame made a little wider could do the trick. The width for stability and with something like 12" diameter toons, that would still keep you close enough to kick. That is the width of my big pontoon toons and it has the flat frame. But you are right, they are rated low as far as weight capacity (200). Yes, the wider, the more stable but with very short pontoons the leverage from waves and currents hitting end on may become an issue, from what I have experienced. Much stability and some buoyancy is gained by having your butt touch the water.
But, actually, just the seat of my hubby gets wet. I could probably get away with hippers.

As far as frames, Aluminum is light and need a special welder. Mine is steel, she didn’t have aluminum then and this frame is every bit as strong as the big boats. Plus a custom YELLOW powder coat.

It does have blunt ends but they sweep up. It is very mobil and can scoot.
I have been out in it during some ruff water and it was very stable and cut through the water just fine. In fact I think I get more wet from my H3 in choppy water.

If you take a look at Denny Rickard’s choice the Super Cat, it too has more or less a blunt end, just rounded off and no sweep up, but people swear by this boat. I have seen Denny fly in that boat I have some of the original 5’ super cat pontoons in the attic from before the company was sold. They are more stable than my 6’ pointed bucks bag pontoons, but much slower with my 25 watt prop power according to the measured watts draw and knotmeter I use. I also notice quite a difference when you are fighting waves, current, or even a 2’ wake when you point them to slice through. A human’s legs can produce spurts of 500 watts, so flying is possible even with a blunt ended boat. **Would surprize me to see 2.5 knots maintained for a dozen miles with kickboat fins though. Something like the hobie pedal boat might exceed that though, or perhaps this system might:
http://www.prophish.com or
http://www.nativewatercraft.com/media/videos/philip_propel/propel_intro.cfm
**

I understand the draw on the power with more of a foot print. My motor on my Pontoon is perfect and I can turn it to where the blade is barely turning and it still moves me, but on my Navigator II (a very large “V” boat) it takes more power to move me. As you said, the butt in the water thing or a BIG foot print. The strange thing is, the V is far more stable.
In a Pontoon and the wind and waves kick up, you do have to concentrate on staying straight not to mention a little Toon slapping.
In the V boat, it doesn’t want to drift, it stays straight and it rows very fast plus I think I move better with my flippers than I do on my Pontoon.

I do see the future Tooners going more in The V or Zodiac shape. It just makes so much sense…One tube will always be more stable than two.
Plus My Navi is a 9’ rowable/motorable/kickable Pontoon. NO FRAME, folds up very tiny and fits in small cars. It don’t get better than that.

Plus My Navi is a 9’ rowable/motorable/kickable Pontoon. NO FRAME, folds up very tiny and fits in small cars. It don’t get better than that.

Wow, the Navi sounds like something I would be interested in. Got any pics of the motor setup you could share? I googled around some and found several different navigator models but didn’t see anything that looked like a 9 footer. Which model keeps your rear end the greatest distance away from the water? Thanks.

Pon

Sadly, I am not sure NFO still makes them or if they have been replaced with the Outlaw, but he might still have some in stock.

Here is how it packs up:

Here it is with oars:

The back of the boat has a zipper. Unzip and stick motor through:

The Optional shelf is diamond plate aluminum, light weight but strong.
Not only holds battery but room for allot of other things. We chose to add Scoty rod holders:

Thanks for the pics. I really like how compact the whole thing is when deflated. The seat looks like it clears the water pretty well which is a necessity for me, how far are you sitting from water? Looks like propulsion is backward like is most of my units. One thing that has helped is a 7 X 9" blind spot mirror I got at an auto store and can quick attaceh/detach on one pontoon to generally see behind me and reduce having to twist my neck to see behind. Do you inflate/deflate on site each time for use? Might not be able to use the ratchet straps to tie overhead on my compact car in the inflated position, which helps if you have to move to different locations. Many, well thought out design adaptations!

Pon

Thanks for the pics. I really like how compact the whole thing is when deflated. The seat looks like it clears the water pretty well which is a necessity for me, how far are you sitting from water?
Just sitting on glass smooth water, I clear about 4". With waves or even the motion of rowing, your back side will get wet, but even my Hubby at 225 isn’t sitting IN the water. The bottom of the inflatable seat is touching.

Looks like propulsion is backward like is most of my units. One thing that has helped is a 7 X 9" blind spot mirror I got at an auto store and can quick attaceh/detach on one pontoon to generally see behind me and reduce having to twist my neck to see behind.

You must fish some busy waters, cause I generally don’t care what is behind me. I can turn around easy enough. I think I would be asking for trouble mounting a mirror[crazy] I don’t turn my upper body around that much, just a kick of one leg or the other and I can see all around.

Do you inflate/deflate on site each time for use? Might not be able to use the ratchet straps to tie overhead on my compact car in the inflated position, which helps if you have to move to different locations. Many, well thought out design adaptations!

Pon

** Yes we usually inflate/deflate. With the LVM pump it is no big deal. And we don’t have to adjust the pontoons because they
are one piece so to speak (two bladders). Just like inflating a SFC or any “V” tube. The fact this is 9’ doesn’t really take that much more time to inflate.

It has to be deflated in My Suzuki as I don’t have the cross bars on my roof rack. We have hauled them inflated with the Chevy and they both fit in the back with a little adjusting and the tailgate left open. But, generally they do get deflated. Specially up camping…out of sight, out of mind thing.**