Hey Craig one other disclaimer you should add is ice conditions are subject to change. Just because the ice is good today, doesn’t mean it will be good tomorrow… Currents, sun, wind and lots of things can change conditions so use these values as starting points but final safety is in your hands… feet, or spud bars… i know many of you have probably seen the youtube blogger that went through the ice this year and lost all his gear and later fished it out with his boat… Seeing how sketchy the ice was when he was leaving the shore, being new ice, he should have never went out… In the spring when the edges go bad, you can justify it a little more, but when it’s new ice and the main body of ice doesn’t have the safety of a good black ice layer underneath an iffy surface it’s just time to stay off the ice… Anyway it will be here soon, but it’s definitely that time of year when you have to practice good ice safety. We haven’t had the big super cold temps to make a great ice sheet this year, we have got an ice sheet that is building a little and melting some, then building some more and melting some more and so it’s a different situation than usual first ice years, so be very careful this year, it’s not business as usual this year… so treat it will respect and caution… Like Craig says we don’t want drownings… Be safe… Jeff
Any updates on Scofield?
Thanks
No, but I may go later in the week and post an update.
Drove around Mantua on the way home from Bear Lake this afternoon. A large part of the lake has a thin layer of ice…with only maybe10% along the west side still open water. If the breezes don’t rip off what is there it shouldn’t be too long before it is fishable. Mantua always caps before Willard…usually about the second week of December.
‘TubeDude’ pid=‘1108167’ dateline=‘1606948256’ wrote:
Drove around Mantua on the way home from Bear Lake this afternoon. A large part of the lake has a thin layer of ice…with only maybe10% along the west side still open water. If the breezes don’t rip off what is there it shouldn’t be too long before it is fishable. Mantua always caps before Willard…usually about the second week of December.
Thanks for the report Pat, how did the whitefish trip turn out? I haven’t seen a post yet… Sure seems like a different ice year, we usually had to have a real cold spell set in to lock up Mantua and then it capped quick, but this slow ice progression this year is really different. I’ve been watching the ice on the back sloughs off Cutler grow in the shady areas to the point that I probably could fish it now, but it’s been a week building from 1.5" to probably 3" now… but if you get out to where the sun hits the ice it’s still under 2" and won’t hold this fat boy… Two more work days and I’ll give it a try, unless I can sneak up after work… Later Jeff
‘SkunkedAgain’ pid=‘1108196’ dateline=‘1607001810’ wrote:
‘TubeDude’ pid=‘1108167’ dateline=‘1606948256’ wrote:
Drove around Mantua on the way home from Bear Lake this afternoon. A large part of the lake has a thin layer of ice…with only maybe10% along the west side still open water. If the breezes don’t rip off what is there it shouldn’t be too long before it is fishable. Mantua always caps before Willard…usually about the second week of December.
***Thanks for the report Pat, how did the whitefish trip turn out? ***
Not much to report. Only got in a couple of hours on the water before those east winds came up and blew us off the water. Anchor wouldn’t hold and a lot of bouncing. BUT…we did catch some whitefish…and one cutt. The fact that we caught fish on a spot that did not hold any on Monday may show that the fish are moving in now. Oh, and I had ice in my guides all the time…at 15 degrees…so I guess this qualifies as an ice report.
‘bhallows’ pid=‘1108153’ dateline=‘1606935117’ wrote:
Any updates on Scofield?
Thanks
There’s 3.5in in the dam arm and it is getting fished, not sure about the rest of the lake. Be safe & prepared on 1st ice and don’t go alone.
‘TubeDude’ pid=‘1108197’ dateline=‘1607003186’ wrote:
‘SkunkedAgain’ pid=‘1108196’ dateline=‘1607001810’ wrote:
‘TubeDude’ pid=‘1108167’ dateline=‘1606948256’ wrote:
Drove around Mantua on the way home from Bear Lake this afternoon. A large part of the lake has a thin layer of ice…with only maybe10% along the west side still open water. If the breezes don’t rip off what is there it shouldn’t be too long before it is fishable. Mantua always caps before Willard…usually about the second week of December.
***Thanks for the report Pat, how did the whitefish trip turn out? ***
Not much to report. Only got in a couple of hours on the water before those east winds came up and blew us off the water. Anchor wouldn’t hold and a lot of bouncing. BUT…we did catch some whitefish…and one cutt. The fact that we caught fish on a spot that did not hold any on Monday may show that the fish are moving in now. Oh, and I had ice in my guides all the time…at 15 degrees…so I guess this qualifies as an ice report.
That is the tough part of that whitefishing that dang wind really ruins a full day trip… And I’ll call it an ice report for sure, ya know I’ve been way colder doing the white fish trip than I ever get fishing on the ice… It’s a cold excursion for sure… Glad you were able to get a few in the boat before the wind ruined the rest of the day… Thanks for that update… Jeff
Drove by Mantua, caped this morning by noon I could see some open water, unsure on thickness, not a soul out there. Not much help but with the warm weather I think it’ll be a while…
‘Fritzfishin’ pid=‘1108236’ dateline=‘1607038503’ wrote:
Drove by Mantua, caped this morning by noon I could see some open water, unsure on thickness, not a soul out there. Not much help but with the warm weather I think it’ll be a while…
Sure hope you’re not right
Echo is almost capped. I drove by this afternoon on my way to work and saw that. I am gonna say 2 weeks until safe ice in my book. I dont get on unless it has at least 4 inches. No fish is worth going through the ice. I have not had that happen and I don’t plan on it anytime soon. My two cents.
Gabe
‘Freakyfisherman’ pid=‘1108249’ dateline=‘1607046916’ wrote:
Echo is almost capped. I drove by this afternoon on my way to work and saw that. I am gonna say 2 weeks until safe ice in my book. I dont get on unless it has at least 4 inches. No fish is worth going through the ice. I have not had that happen and I don’t plan on it anytime soon. My two cents.
Gabe
I drove by it too. Yesterday the cap busted all up in the wind. I am also not in a hurry to get wet. I can play parchessie and eat chex mix while I wait for it.
x2 on the chex mix. I have it from a reliable source that there is 2" ice on Mantua, and that some brave souls were fishing it. Quite a way from being thick enough for me. I always miss out on the early season bite there because I insist on 4". Seems a lot of people start fishing it when it gets to 3-3.5".
‘Fritzfishin’ pid=‘1108236’ dateline=‘1607038503’ wrote:
Drove by Mantua, caped this morning by noon I could see some open water, unsure on thickness, not a soul out there. Not much help but with the warm weather I think it’ll be a while…
I got curious and looked up a formula for this. Every year I’m bouncing in my chair at this point, thinking it’ll be time any MINUTE now. I’m sure reality will vary with solar exposure and latitude, moving water, or warm springs, etc. but the formula is science-based.
For instance, I remember once hand drilling a dozen holes through 16" of ice in a shaded gully at the Gorge, reporting so on BFT, and getting flamed like a criminal for NOT warning people that the Confluence wasn’t frozen over. So, don’t stake your life on JUST the math here.
Once a lake as capped with ice which doesn’t melt off during the day…Add the high and low temp over 24 hours and divide by two. Take that number and subtract from 32 F. Divide that number by 15. That’s how much ice will form in that 24 hours.
So, today at Mantua, the high should be 38 and the low is 15. (38+15) / 2=26.5. 32-2.5= 5.5 5.5/15= 0.367 Barring a warm wind, etc…the lake will add about 3/8" of new ice thickness in 24 hours.
Tomorrow, warmer. 39 +17 averages to 28, 32 - 28 = 4. 4/15=0.267, so barely more than a quarter of an inch.
I mean… im not good at math and stuff but!!! To me colder weather=more ice ?
‘Fritzfishin’ pid=‘1108295’ dateline=‘1607106190’ wrote:
I mean… im not good at math and stuff but!!! To me colder weather=more ice ?
Well, yes. I’m not a math-brain either, but this is 4th grade level, so I thought I might tackle it. Gives me an idea if I should try it this week or next.
I’m gonna go join the crowd at Scofield tomorrow I think, 3.5" jigs tipped with a chunk of yuba carp for a tiger trout worthy of the contest
I’ve gotten reports that the ice is 6-7 inches thick at Madsen Bay.
Bump to move this thread to the top.
I fished AF Boat Harbor Saturday night from about 4 pm to 8:30. Ice was 2-3" thick on the shaded spots and in some open places, and a thick skim on the sunny side and right against the docks. Some kids fooling around, walking on the sketchy ice. One other angler. Banged holes in the ice and fished from docks.
I caught a handful of perch on medium-sized ice jigs and crawlers/perch bits. Funny enough, the WB were slow at first, and picked up to a steady, but not fast pace about sunset and I caught them well past dark on some larger, glowing jigs. Sonar Lure got me a few, too. I forgot how late it was and took home 24.