Fishing report pier by Mead Marina 10/17

How to clean a turtle


So, by some method, you have come into the possession of 1 or more legally edible turtles. Congratulations! They are legendarily good eating. Or, if you’re into catching, cleaning, and eating turtles, there’s a good chance that you might refer to them as good eatin’, if that makes any difference.

What do you do with it (them)? Well, that’s where this instructable comes into play.

  1. Put live turtle in a 55 gal. drum for 7 days, to allow it to empty it’s system, it helps with the smell. Keep fresh water in the drum. Scoop out the feces with a net.

  2. Using channel locks, hold him tight by the mouth with neck stretched out. Cut off his head.

  3. Hang him upside down to bleed out for about 30 minutes.

  4. Put him on his back, cut claws and feet off.

  5. Cut skin around shell top and bottom, cut and pull skin away from shell on the front legs until skin is removed.

  6. On the soft shell belly outside edge of shell, cut through soft shell contact points and remove.

  7. Remove guts and innards.

  8. Remove front legs, may need to twist to break the joint.

  9. Cut and peel skin from back legs and neck.

  10. Remove back legs and neck, again twisting to break joints.

  11. Leave meat on bone, but try to remove as much fat as possible.

  12. Wash with cold water, repeat until clean.

  13. Freeze submerged in water.

Many thanks to Chad Glidden for sharing this information.

Chad says to cook the turtle like you would chicken. Season it with paprika, salt and pepper and roll in flour. Fry in a skillet or bake it like a pork tenderloin.

EAT THAT UGLY BUGGER

Southern Twice Fried Turtle
Our thanks to Bruce R. for sending this recipe.

~ 1 medium sized soft shell turtle, cut into serving size pieces
~ 2 cups flour
~ 1 tbsp black pepper
~ 1 tsp salt
~ 1 tsp garlic salt
~ 1 tsp onion powder
~ 1 tsp paprika
~ oil

In a large bowl, combine all of the dry ingredients

Fill a large cast iron skillet half full of oil. Heat to 325 degrees.

Coat the turtle pieces in the flour mixture and place in the hot oil.

Once turtle is browned, reduce heat to medium. After the oil has cooled to a slow fry, remove skillet from heat and add 1 cup of water. BE CAREFUL!!! Remember to remove the skillet from the stove in case of boil over. Remember oil and water don’t like to mix. USE CAUTION!

Return the skillet to the stove. Cover and cook until all of the water has cooked out.

Uncover and fry turtle until it starts to get crispy. Remove and drain.

Serve with your favorite side dishes such as gravy, grits and biscuits.

Enjoy!

So, I have to stay at the lake for a week while my dinner flushes itself out?

According to NDOW we can not take anything out of the park alive. (fish, frogs and crawfish) Does this include turtles?

Yeah, that would mean turtles too.

. Must have picture proof :laughing:

I can’t wait to see the pics for this challenge.

I thought I would throw in my experience with these turtles. I have caught them all over the lake in the last 25 years and always just threw em back. Then I heard they were supposedly real good to eat. So I had caught a pretty good sized one about 18 inches in diameter and threw him in the cooler. When I got home he was dead from the cold ice chest. I didn’t have any recipe I just started cutting. The shell was a real pain to remove. Once I removed the top of the shell I was shocked to see more guts inside than any fish I had ever cleaned. It seemed as if he had two of everything inside. The only real meat was his four legs and a little of meat attached to them. I fried it up and it was just OK in my opinion and not worth the hassle. I have ever since then always returned them to the water. I do remember several years ago on a camping trip just outside Callville it was early in the morning and my girlfriend was hollering she had a big fish and could’nt reel him in. So I grabbed the pole and fought this thing for a while and when we got it near the shore we were blown away by the size of this turtle. It was the size of a full size trash can lid. I am talking 30 inches in diameter. I just cut the line cuz this thing was a hissing and snapping and looked like it could easily take off a couple fingers

iam pretty red neck but this is even too much for me

You know that we will have to try if we get one. I say we have a contest to see who on this forum could catch and eat the first turtle. Must have picture proof :laughing:

O hell no[:p] What could possibly be the prize?