I would say that a good place to try is Wellsville Reservoir. The DWR keeps it well stocked and I think they have stocked some wiper in there besides all the rainbows.
They should have a good chance of getting into some fish if they are just learning.
If you go to Benson Marina and you fish near the road bridge from the banks on either side, be sure you have everyone hang on to their poles. Cuz as soon as you let go of the pole, and set it down somewhere without a good pole holder, a big Carp or Catfish will come along and swipe the bait, line, pole, everything.
Thanks for all the suggestions. Benson and Wellsville were also the two spots I thought would be most likely to get us into fish. We ended up at First Dam because they were going to be over that way and we actually had a great time. Everyone caught fish. But I’ll have to go try to get into some wipers at Wellsville next week. The couple we took fishing are hooked and were talking about going every weekend.
Some friends asked us to help them learn how to fish on a lake from the shore. They should’ve asked someone else we’ve gone a couple of times and been skunked so far. Any thoughts on the best body of water near Cache Valley to help some beginners land some fish?