Unsure on which tube to buy

[orvis1]

Having owned both your decision is easy. If you want to save the money get the creek company tube. Go on e-bay and you can get one new with fins and pump for under 100 dollars shipped to you. You will hate the valves and eventually end up upgrading later.

The fish cat is a better built tube and the valves are sewn in! I would get the foam seat model if you want to sit higher but you can always order the inflatable seat for backpacking.

Koke is right though if you can save up I love my scadden!
[signature]