10-03-2010, 12:51 AM
This is probably about as productive as trying to travel to the Orient by continental drift, but one last swipe on this dead horse.
RE:"You need to take another look at what goes on at Deer creek...
There is and have been many fish over the size limit taken out of there each day"
As you know, NO big bass have been taken out of there LEGALLY for about 13 years. While there may be occasional poaching there, it is a stretch that even you cannot make to say that DC has so much more poaching than Jordanelle, Utah lake and many of our other bass lakes where we can routinely still catch fish over 12 inches on most trips. In my opinion, Utah lake and Jordanelle have far more bass poaching than DC on "over the slot" fish.
E" The truth is that if you take out the bigger fish of any type all you do is make room for more small fish..... "
Regarding DC, What we are talking about is taking out
the surplus of small fish so the rest can have a chance to grow faster. There aren't many big fish to take out.
RE"the big thing is FOOD for the fish or bass as we are talking about on this post..
YESSSS, we are ALL talking about food!!! (Maybe you do understand a little). In the case of DC, too many predatory mouths for the very scarce available food.
It has always amazes me that some anglers (both trouters and bassers) will hold to a dogmatic 100% C&R belief with religious zeal. I suppose it will always defy logical argument.
There, this horse is pretty tenderized.[
]
[signature]
RE:"You need to take another look at what goes on at Deer creek...
There is and have been many fish over the size limit taken out of there each day"
As you know, NO big bass have been taken out of there LEGALLY for about 13 years. While there may be occasional poaching there, it is a stretch that even you cannot make to say that DC has so much more poaching than Jordanelle, Utah lake and many of our other bass lakes where we can routinely still catch fish over 12 inches on most trips. In my opinion, Utah lake and Jordanelle have far more bass poaching than DC on "over the slot" fish.
E" The truth is that if you take out the bigger fish of any type all you do is make room for more small fish..... "
Regarding DC, What we are talking about is taking out
the surplus of small fish so the rest can have a chance to grow faster. There aren't many big fish to take out.
RE"the big thing is FOOD for the fish or bass as we are talking about on this post..
YESSSS, we are ALL talking about food!!! (Maybe you do understand a little). In the case of DC, too many predatory mouths for the very scarce available food.
It has always amazes me that some anglers (both trouters and bassers) will hold to a dogmatic 100% C&R belief with religious zeal. I suppose it will always defy logical argument.
There, this horse is pretty tenderized.[
][signature]