06-02-2009, 02:51 PM
[quote Brook]>The only other problem I see with building your own at this point, is you have no idea what taper/action you want. And there is no way to test this on a blank. <
While this is true, FG, it's also true for choosing a finished rod. A beginner has no way of rationally choosing a taper/action because (s)he hasn't a clue what that really means.
Although fly shop personnel usually can be a big help in this regard, so much depends on personal style and preference, and the kind of fishing being done, that such a choice can only be made after you get some experience under your belt.
Brook[/quote]
Absolutely. So, why should a newbie now take on the art of building a rod on top of learning. I think that is way down the road after you figured out you love it and want just the right stick.
I see nothing wrong with slow action rods. In fact I prefer new comers to use them as, I feel they teach the RIGHT way or you end up with a mess.
Fast action has it's place, but I feel allot of new comers go to fast as it HIDES mistakes and does not aid in creating a good caster.
The crawl before the walk thing.
There are the CHEAPO Walmart Specials with even Orvis knock offs. Shakesphere is not a terrible starter. Not great but not terrible.
I too remember when SA was a good mid priced reel. But they have their budget line now as everyone else does.
When I come across a beginner that is showing definite long term interest, I would recommend ORVIS Clearwater set up. It is reasonably priced and covered for 25 years.
Launch is another rod I would recommend. The thing is, they are both USA made and a great price.
[signature]
While this is true, FG, it's also true for choosing a finished rod. A beginner has no way of rationally choosing a taper/action because (s)he hasn't a clue what that really means.
Although fly shop personnel usually can be a big help in this regard, so much depends on personal style and preference, and the kind of fishing being done, that such a choice can only be made after you get some experience under your belt.
Brook[/quote]
Absolutely. So, why should a newbie now take on the art of building a rod on top of learning. I think that is way down the road after you figured out you love it and want just the right stick.
I see nothing wrong with slow action rods. In fact I prefer new comers to use them as, I feel they teach the RIGHT way or you end up with a mess.
Fast action has it's place, but I feel allot of new comers go to fast as it HIDES mistakes and does not aid in creating a good caster.
The crawl before the walk thing.
There are the CHEAPO Walmart Specials with even Orvis knock offs. Shakesphere is not a terrible starter. Not great but not terrible.
I too remember when SA was a good mid priced reel. But they have their budget line now as everyone else does.
When I come across a beginner that is showing definite long term interest, I would recommend ORVIS Clearwater set up. It is reasonably priced and covered for 25 years.
Launch is another rod I would recommend. The thing is, they are both USA made and a great price.
[signature]