10-24-2006, 05:41 PM
No offense, but maxing out at 14 inch rainbows is not my idea of nice sized fish. I have fished cave lake, and as you stated you can catch a lot of small planters. Cave lake is not good IMHO for nice rainbows, if you are patient and lucky there are nice browns in there but they are few and far between. Comins is the place for good sized rainbows 2.5-5lb rainbows being the norm. Yes it is weedy late in the year but early it is nice. Otter Creek in UT is just a bit farther but if you want the same type of action as Cave lake with decent size (2lb avg) it is so much nicer. Cave lake is beautiful, but for great fishing i would not reccomend it. just my humble opinion. I have heard that they are going to lay off the heavy stocking and try and get some bigger fish iin there though.
[signature]
[signature]