Fish smell - Printable Version +- Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum) +-- Forum: Idaho Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=353) +--- Forum: Idaho Fishing General (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=25) +--- Thread: Fish smell (/showthread.php?tid=820400)

Fish smell - Whale81 - 05-16-2013 I've always made an effort to keep sunscreen, bug spray, tobacco etc away from lures and flies. I have a streamer box full of flies that got doused in sunscreen last year I thought I would have to chuck in the trash. You can smell the flies from 5 feet away. I used a few yesterday carp fishing and guess what? The fish didn't care a bit! Carp are supposed to have an exceptional sense of taste and smell. Anyone had a lure get contaminated and not work, or is it amyth like bringing bananas in the boat? [signature] Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - monkeee2002 - 05-16-2013 Maybe they like coconut? LoL! I've always heard the same thing. But, I smoke, and smoke while I fish. I'm anti-west nile virus, so I wear bug spray. I try not to get any spray on my hands, but I'm sure some ends up there. My experience is that when the fish are biting, they don't seem to care much. But, it's not like I hose down my tackle box with deet, either. [signature] Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - cpierce - 05-16-2013 You must have hit on one combination they like. Maybe you would be interested in these articles: http://www.bigfishtackle.com/cgi-bin/gforum/gforum.cgi?post=614081 Use the links at the bottom of the first post [signature] Re: [cpierce] Fish smell - Whale81 - 05-16-2013 Interesting article. Thanks for the link. I'm still picturing the fishing guide trying to explain why the tube of Prep-h is in his fishing bag! Maybe No-Ad spf15 is some kind of miracle fish attractant, but I'm holding off on a full endorsement for now. [signature] Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - Paulpro - 05-16-2013 Banana in boat myth busted in Florida! not utah[:p] Banana in boat at[#FF0000] 0:13[/#FF0000] in this video,400 Bass DAY! only in Florida can't do this in UTAH! [url "http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BUHDXY8PCaU"] [/url] [url "http://youtu.be/BUHDXY8PCaU"]http://youtu.be/BUHDXY8PCaU[/url] The boys always joke about me bringing a banana on board lol [signature] Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - dtayboyz - 05-17-2013 I think it has more to do with getting the human smell off the bait. Had an old guy in Hagerman tell me that years ago when he was teaching me about sturgeon. He also said "He who gathers the bait off the screens catches the most fish" RIP Mutt Smith [signature] Re: [Paulpro] Fish smell - jeremypeace - 05-17-2013 Your just showing off now [signature] Re: [jeremypeace] Fish smell - Paulpro - 05-17-2013 sup Jeremy,nah..none of the fish were even over 2lb,it wuz more about myth busting,and making fun The Banana is always a good excuse for the boys when they had an off day or whatever dats why I always bring it P [signature] Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - outdoorsman1 - 05-19-2013 I fished with a guide that had been guiding for 20 years and the plastic that I was using got torn up and he super glued it back together and told me to go back to fishing. I said "dont they smell that?" and he said "it doesn't seem to bother them" needless to say I caught another fish right after that. Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - flygoddess - 05-19-2013 I do believe fish can smell, and I too "USE" to smoke and always caught more fish than anyone with me, so I assumed they liked tobacco. Anise oil (licorice) is a good cover up so is vanilla. As far as Carp not interested, I fish for Carp almost every day. They are not interested in my flies the last few days. I am not a biologist at all and the way they are swimming together, jumping out of the water, I assumed they were in spawn mode and during that time it is tough to get them to hit. I still catch them, but I truly have to work for it. [signature] Re: [Whale81] Fish smell - futekisenshi - 05-23-2013 I fish completely covered up; long sleeves, pants, gloves, buff, wide brimmed hat. Everything has SPF protection and it's loose fitting, so bugs can't get through it. Everything is made of lightweight materials too, and with the sun not directly on my skin, I feel I stay cooler as well. No cancer rays and no need to deal with sunscreen or bug spray. [] Although if you want a nice tan, this is definitely not the way to go. [] [signature] Re: [outdoorsman1] Fish smell - Tarponjim - 05-23-2013 [quote outdoorsman1]I fished with a guide that had been guiding for 20 years and the plastic that I was using got torn up and he super glued it back together and told me to go back to fishing. I said "dont they smell that?" and he said "it doesn't seem to bother them" needless to say I caught another fish right after that.[/quote] I've been going through a whole lot of glue lately! The more "chewed and glued" they get, the better they're working! As for the banana "myth", that's as FACT as anything in fishing. You can put whatever you want on your fly or lure, but don't EVER bring the banana on my boat or we're doomed. Never. [signature] Re: [Tarponjim] Fish smell - outdoorsman1 - 05-23-2013 Aww Jim dont tell them all your secrets!!!![] . [signature]