+- Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Idaho Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=353)
+--- Forum: Idaho Fishing General (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=25)
+--- Thread: where are all the bows coming from? (/showthread.php?tid=767413)
where are all the bows coming from? - michael44 - 08-21-2012
I fish the snake around Shelly a lot, and have always done well on big browns, In the last couple weeks it seems like all my favorite spots are over run with scads and scads of small rainbows, I can't keep them off the line and don't really like catching them.
My question is why are they there? obviously they are planters. The f&g website seems to be down and I can't get to the fish stocking reports.
I have fished this stretch of river for years and it has never been a "hotspot" for rainbows.
I would rather catch 1 big brown than 30 10-12" bows.
[frown]
[signature]
Re: [michael44] where are all the bows coming from? - Chris_S - 08-21-2012
I would think a big brown could eat a 10" rainbow pretty easily. I would be happy...all those browns you were catching should now be on high protein trout diet
[signature]
Re: [michael44] where are all the bows coming from? - idaho_grizz - 08-22-2012
Put and take trout is about all the F & G know, also they had a draw listed so their is down. Happen every time, I wish they would update there site
[signature]
Re: [michael44] where are all the bows coming from? - brownieguy - 08-22-2012
I ran a stretch up there last week and had the same thing, we still managed a couple nice fish but we did hit a bunch of little bows. I'm ok with them tossing them in there because a good number do feed the big boys and others become big boys.
[signature]
Re: [brownieguy] where are all the bows coming from? - Bmarsh - 08-22-2012
I'm to the point I think the stocking so much is sort of a joke. I sure would rather see our resources put into things that will help our fisheries long term like spawing area improvements, erosion control ect. Than just throwing money away with stocking.
[signature]
Re: [Bmarsh] where are all the bows coming from? - jigs - 08-23-2012
i belive many of us would agree but there are a whole lot more weekend fisherman that would rather catch 20 fish than 1 large fish, and also lack the skill to catch the larger ones. and without these licenses they would be loosing money
[signature]
Re: [jigs] where are all the bows coming from? - Bmarsh - 08-23-2012
If you work on improving habitat, and spawning beds you produce a longer term fishery with the type of 20 fish days you would want plus Tue chance to yank in big ones. Instead a bunch of planters are released with all short term and no long term impact. It's similiar to the pheasant planting......you put a semi wild animal into a wild setting.....short term is game/ fish to harvest but in the long terms islicense $ down the toilet
[signature]
Re: [Bmarsh] where are all the bows coming from? - michael44 - 08-23-2012
Just for me personally it ticks me off, If I want to catch a bunch of little bows I would go to ryder park pond.
It makes it harder to catch a decent fish because you are spending all your time catching and releasing a bunch of crappy little planters.
especially when you are floating the river in a toon.
I'm thinking they planted them at Shelly park and they have spread up and down the river.
I guess it is time to burn a bit more gas and head to the north fork or henry's.
[signature]
Re: [michael44] where are all the bows coming from? - riverdog - 08-25-2012
+1, nothing worse than returning to a productive river than to end up being tortured by stupid planted bows. Sure a few really big fish get bigger but they compete with and stunt the medium size fish for years to come. Ending up with far fewer fish over 20 inches in a year or 2. As far as where they're coming from it's usually F&G that is so uptight about making their quota of planters that they shoot for 30% more than they need. Like only getting 80-90% of goal occasionally would be such a horrible thing. They then end up with more fish than they know what to do with and dump them where they shouldn't go. I refer to such waters as bow hell and stay away for a few years unless I got a newbie to get started. Did take a friend that never flied fished before to one such bow hell. He caught more than a dozen fish an hour with no instruction on how to fish until he was on stream. I didn't cast once. Not other practical use for such waters.
[signature]