+- Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum)
+-- Forum: Idaho Fishing Forum (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=353)
+--- Forum: Idaho Fishing General (https://bigfishtackle.com/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=25)
+--- Thread: First Fish On A Fly (/showthread.php?tid=753786)
First Fish On A Fly - the_cactus_kid - 06-17-2012
Took up learning how to fly fish on Silver Creek this week. Figured since I'd be here for two weeks, I ought to learn how to swing flies. Of course, everyone said I'll get my butt kicked on Silver Creek - it's not ideal for rookies.
Oh well, I'm sure that's true. I've caught a couple, and missed a few. Having fun anyway, and starting to get the hang of it.
A little brown, but boy was I happy to catch something!
[inline "brown 06 16 12.jpg"]
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - brownieguy - 06-17-2012
Hey congrats on getting that first fish on a fly! The next step is tying up your own stuff and getting them on flies that you tied for yourself, definitely gratifying.
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - windriver - 06-17-2012
What made you think that Silver Creek would be the place to start?[cool] I haven't gotten the confidence to try Silver Creek yet. Probably all of those fishing articles talking about spending all day stalking a single trout, making 90 ft casts with a three weight, and fishing size 26 flies that has scared me off thus far. Maybe I will have to give it a try sometime. I know it is beautiful.
Windriver
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - Nick1983 - 06-17-2012
Nicely done! Fly fishing is addictive, I still remember my first on the fly. Yours was a brown on reputable water. Mine was an 8" stocker on the boise. You win hahaha
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - forrest2906 - 06-17-2012
congrats. I remember the first one icaught on a fly that I tied....made me laugh that something that i tied was actually fish worthy.
Makes you feel all good inside.
HAGD
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - StickRig - 06-18-2012
Nice! My first one on the fly was caught by accident on the Teton. I was learning the basics and had a whopping 3 incher take my fly.
[signature]
Re: [windriver] First Fish On A Fly - the_cactus_kid - 06-18-2012
@ WindRiver: you know the saying, fools rush in...
Thanks everybody!
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - cpierce - 06-18-2012
Awesome! A first fish on the fly from Silver Creek is an accomplishment to remember!!
[signature]
Re: [StickRig] First Fish On A Fly - the_cactus_kid - 06-18-2012
@ StickRig: haha, you caught me! The title of this thread was misleading. Technically, the first fish I caught on a fly was this one...(help me out veterans - is this a brown trout minnow, or what?)
[inline IMG_0143.jpg]
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - cpierce - 06-18-2012
I can't see it well enough to be sure, but there doesn't look like there is any adipose fin. So not a trout.
Some kind of very hungry minnow!
[signature]
Re: [cpierce] First Fish On A Fly - the_cactus_kid - 06-20-2012
Bumping this back to the top because I just had to share my 2nd fish on a fly (3rd if you count the minnow!). This big brown made my 3 wt. rod bend for a good fight. Now I feel like I really caught something on Silver Creek!
[inline "brown in hand 06 19 12.jpg"]
[signature]
Re: [the_cactus_kid] First Fish On A Fly - Fishit - 06-20-2012
Good goin! Silver Creek is tough water to fish, but very rewarding when you do well.
[signature]
Re: [Fishit] First Fish On A Fly - Kodiak1 - 06-20-2012
Starting fly fishing on Silver Creek is sort of like starting mountain climbing on K2! It's all downhill from here on out. Congrats. Mike
[signature]
Re: [cpierce] First Fish On A Fly - mojorizing - 06-21-2012
[quote cpierce]I can't see it well enough to be sure, but there doesn't look like there is any adipose fin. So not a trout.
Some kind of very hungry minnow![/quote]P
Cindy, it's a brown. If you look closely, the adipose is slicked back. Probably because it's in a net. Greaser fish from the '50's.
[signature]
Re: [mojorizing] First Fish On A Fly - the_cactus_kid - 06-21-2012
Thanks all for the kind words. If you head Silver Creek way, stop in and talk to Bob at the Picabo Convenience store. He's very helpful, and sells you the right flys.
Thanks for clearing up what kind of a minnow that was. I just noticed it had a pretty bright orange stripe. Is that unique to browns?
[signature]
Re: [mojorizing] First Fish On A Fly - cpierce - 06-21-2012
Good job on seeing that. I am not sure that I can see one. It certainly has a brown's appetite that fly is bigger than its head!
It looks a lot like a shiner considering the other fins and no spots, but I am not a baby fish expert. I usually backcast most of the little guys I catch. Then I scramble around looking for the little buggers!
[signature]